I attended the high school on the eastern side of my South Texas home town. It was considered better than the high schools that served the center and west sides of the city, and people often moved to the area to get their children into the school.

As a result, the eastern side of McAllen, Texas, had the highest property values. The nicest neighborhoods, the fanciest mansions and most expensive apartments all fed directly into my high school. When my parents bought a home in McAllen, they chose a newish middle-class neighborhood to take advantage of what they considered the best options.

No matter what their politics or their values, most parents I know would do the same. It’s human. And it’s exactly what’s about to happen to Pittsburgh Public Schools, if the new proposal goes into effect.

We don’t need no education

The goal is to achieve educational equity. Pittsburgh schools currently have a mixed system of magnets and neighborhood schools.

Advertise with us

Under the proposal that PPS is considering from their educational consultants, it would revert to a more standard education model: neighborhood elementary schools (K-fifth grade) that feed directly into a middle school (sixth-eighth) and then high school (ninth-12th). Two successful magnets would be preserved.

This is not a bad idea in theory. In a world with equal-access to equally good education, this should work just fine. No one questions the need to consolidate and close schools.

But the truth is that the inequalities of the proposed feeder system will soon become apparent. People will move out of neighborhoods whose schools are not deemed as good and into the areas with the perceived better schools — or out of the district altogether.

The magnet system in Pittsburgh was created to avoid this. The jury is out on if it succeeded. But PPS now risks driving more people out of an already struggling system. And, while they don’t seem concerned about the losses, the plan could create even more disparities between neighborhoods — which is not equity by any means.

Hey! Teacher!

All PPS schools should be equally attractive, equally able to educate our children at the highest standards. But equity won’t happen like this. This will only drive up applications to the only magnet program left in the city at the K-5 level, and more students wanting to get into Pittsburgh Montessori does not lift the other schools.

Advertise with us

Rather than build more Montessori-like schools, we might be throwing out the baby with the bathwater. Take for example, the proposal put forth by the PPS-hired consultants regarding gifted programs.

Gifted and talented programs tend to favor children who come from upper middle-class homes, as those are the children with parents with the time and energy to read, promote and help their children succeed academically. We should have them, just as we should have ESL programs and programs for students with different learning abilities.

Right now, other than announcing the closing of the gifted center, the proposal has not explained how they plan to address gifted eduction in the district. Will there be dedicated gifted classrooms or IEPs, for example? Nor do those children seem to be a priority.

Yes, gifted programs tend to favor the wealthier students with more educated parents, who are generally the loudest voices in the room. Still, PPS should better test and identify all students, of all backgrounds, who could be gifted rather than potentially alienate those families. Or as one gifted private school consultant told me, “we are preparing for more parents to defect from PPS than ever.”

Just another brick in the wall

Last week, as PPS platformed the education consultants they hired, a group of parents, led by local nurse Sarah Zangle, put together an alternative proposal. These parents were not paid a quarter million dollars like the consultants, but voluntarily assembled a plan that better worked for their children.

Advertise with us

At the heart of the proposal is a plan for dividing the city into five “regions of choice,” and letting parents rank-choice vote which schools in their region they prefer at the elementary level, with city-wide options for high-schoolers. It’s still a feeder and lottery system, but a fairer one that offers parents some alternatives, albeit small — and lets them feel more in control of their children’s education without having to move to a different neighborhood.

It’s an interesting idea. It’s too bad that PPS didn’t let the parents present during their official meeting. The parents are going rogue, presenting for the public on Tuesday at 6:30 p.m. at the Smithfield United Church of Christ Community Hall.

No word if PPS board members will attend. At least some should go. It offers an opportunity to possibly improve the district and make those directly affected feel more considered.

As PPS parent Mike Cummins told WTAE, “Our message is not that we want to fight with [the district], but we want to help you, right? So we have an open door. We want them to be part of this process, and hear us out, and make the best PPS that we possibly can.”

Adriana E. Ramírez’s previous column was “The myth of late-term abortion.”