The newly admitted freshman class at Sarah Lawrence College had the option to pick two of three different prompts for their application essays. The first two prompts pointed to the school’s unique open curriculum system and the third did something else entirely.
After quoting the essay-writing loophole in the Supreme Court decision banning race-based university admissions, it instructed applicants: “Drawing upon examples from your life, a quality of your character, and/or a unique ability you possess, describe how you believe your goals for a college education might be impacted, influenced or affected by the Court’s decision.”
Dear Sir or Madam
Kevin McKenna, Sarah Lawrence’s dean of admissions, told Inside Higher Ed that “the purpose of the essay question is not to extract details about students’ racial identity for surreptitious use in admissions decisions; rather, it’s to encourage applicants to express their feelings about the court’s ruling and how it will impact the makeup of their future college cohort.”
Students for Fair Admissions, the plaintiffs in the Supreme Court decision, are not buying this logic. In a letter sent out Tuesday, the group “hinted that the essay was going to be a big part of its investigation into admissions procedures,” according to the New York Times.
Under the S.F.F.A.’s scrutiny are Duke, Princeton and Yale’s admission essay options, which parallel the short answer question used by their constant nemesis: “Harvard has long recognized the importance of enrolling a diverse student body. How will the life experiences that shape who you are today enable you to contribute to Harvard?”
Asking students to volunteer information about “who they are” will clearly identify more students of color, the S.F.F.A. claimed. But they were wrong.
In a comprehensive report, “Admissions Essay After S.F.F.A.,” University of Chicago law professor Sonja Starr found that fewer students wrote about their racial identities than in previous years. In fact, as Inside Higher Ed pointed out, “the only group that wrote more about their racial identity were non-Hispanic white students.”
It took me years to write, will you take a look?
Conservative activist Edward Blum founded the S.F.F.A. in 2014 for the express purpose of dismantling affirmative action admissions policies in universities. He got his wish when a conservative-stacked Supreme Court delivered the landmark ruling removing race from admissions.
The case surrounded unfair admission practices against Asian-American students. But a year later, after disregarding race as a factor, Princeton, Duke and Yale roughly maintained their Black and Latino population while significantly decreasing Asian-American enrollment. There was also a palpable increase in students who chose not to reveal their own race.
“Based on S.F.F.A.’s extensive experience, your racial numbers are not possible under true neutrality,” wrote Blum in Tuesday’s letter. The missive went on to suggest the organization will likely be suing those institutions in the near future.
“You are now on notice. Preserve all potentially relevant documents and communications.”
But Blum’s “extensive experience” amounts to mathematical projections and modeling based on previous applicants, their academic levels and rate of admissions. Nothing about that is “true neutrality.” For example, Blum’s projections do not take into account that, once equalized for income and time in the U.S., Asian-American students perform on par, or below, “non-Hispanic white students.” These numbers also don’t take into account the importance of being able to write a good essay.
Writing skills are crucial across professions. A doctor who can write up a good case study, a mechanic who can write up a good report and a mathematician who can write up a good explanation for their proof fare better than those who cannot. The same goes for an artist who can write a good grant application and a musician who can write good lyrics.
The essay and short answer prompts from top universities, which usually include an option that centers around “identity” or the factors that “shape who you are today,” might provoke different responses from different students. I know this because a long time ago, I edited and coached high school students through the process.
I could make it longer if you like the style
What I learned in the two years that I did this job is that the students who were honest and sincere wrote the best essays. I can boast of my student’s first-choice admission rate (85%), but the ones that stick with me are the remaining ones who had to suffer the heartache of rejection.
As their essay writing coach, I could only help them so much. And I can tell you unequivocally that the ones who tried to game the system by writing about fake oppression landed, more often than not, in the heartache group.
Essay prompts are designed to reveal the mind at work, and on that front, we are all individuals — small worlds, of which our race is but a component. There is no “right answer” to an essay, there is only the writer unearthing themselves in what the question provokes.
Students for Fair Admissions fought hard to remove race as a factor in university admissions. And now, as Asian American student populations fall as a consequence, they can only point to the essay as some kind of giant loophole where discussion of race is allowed. But essays are subjective, unlike hard numbers and quotas, and one cannot litigate how people write about their own lives.
In this regard, there is nothing more truly neutral than the blank page.
Previous column: “We need voter ID laws — but only if they bring in more voters.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.