For some parents, receiving state funds to pay for a private education can make all the difference for their children’s success. Other parents believe those funds would be better spent improving existing schools to better serve all students.

Everyone is right, but as much as I hate it in theory, I think the Pennsylvania Award for Student Success (PASS) Scholarship Program might still be worth a try, because whatever is happening now simply isn’t enough.

Lifelines

The idea behind school vouchers is simple: Students should be allowed to use public funds to attend private school. Families, according to advocates of school choice, should be given agency in determining their child’s future.

In Pennsylvania, legislation would create a separate line item in the state’s budget in order to provide those scholarships, $2,500 to $10,000 per student depending on grade level. Anyone requiring special education services can get up to $15,000. The estimated $300 million program would only serve families making less than 250% of federal poverty guidelines who “live within an attendance boundary of a low-achieving school,” defined as schools in the lowest 15% of math and reading scores.

Advertise with us

For one Pittsburgh-area mom, who asked to be called Rachel, it would be a lifeline. “My child requires an [Individualized Education Program plan] and his assigned school was unable to meet it. We felt hopeless. Our only option was a private school we could not afford, and who could not grant us a scholarship because we discovered all this after their deadlines.”

A program like PASS would allow her son to be at the right school, one her family could not afford otherwise.

I spoke to an administrator at a school that serves children like Rachel’s son. He noted that his school already goes to great lengths to work with families to help meet their needs. But he also said that PASS would be a game-changer for his institution.

“Less time fundraising and more time devoted to student-care,” he said, before apologizing for “dreaming out loud.” His school, a smaller institution that aims to reintegrate students back into public school, would reap the rewards of an increased student body. PASS could help institutions like this do more, better.

Who benefits?

The students who will most benefit from PASS are the students whose families are already looking into private school. These are not people who will be attending elite schools with tuition into the $30k range. These are families looking for schools, some specialized in therapeutic support and some religious, that will be able to differently focus on their children’s education.

Advertise with us

“For every parent with a child that requires more than their failing school district can provide, PASS will ensure that they can look elsewhere with confidence,” Rachel told me.

And while advocates for PASS are quick to note that its funding is separate from the state’s education budget, and will not take away from existing public schools, many opponents find that unsustainable.

“They all say that this will end up saving school districts money,” one parent on a local school board wrote to me. “But it’s not true. The math only works if school budgets remain the same. But if more and more kids go private, that only means fewer allocated funds.”

Or as Nicole Hannah-Jones noted on X, “fewer kids in the classroom means fewer dollars to the school.”

The school board parent also argued that school choice has always existed. “People have always had the option to send their children to a private school. The question is why does the public have to pay for it?”

Advertise with us

The math of it all

What no one is talking about is the question at the heart of all the controversy: what is public education?

Is it the schooling provided by public schools? Or is it a dollar amount that any parent can use as they see fit?

That raises other questions: Should failing public schools continue to be funded? Should private schools benefit from public funds without being held to the same standards? Should the public pay for religious institutions, as many private schools in Pennsylvania are religiously affiliated?

There is solid partisan data supporting arguments for and against school choice: Some studies say that after a few years, improvement is seen in all cohorts — students in private school and the students “left behind” at the low-achieving schools. Other studies show little-to-no improvement for students of color and those well-below the poverty line without active parental involvement.

I’m not sure PASS is a good thing. Arizona’s foray into universal school vouchers has been a documented failure — both financially and scholastically. Maybe Pennsylvania’s more targeted approach could work? But whatever we’re doing now isn’t working. Math and reading scores do not lie.

Advertise with us

I bought into a different idea of public education, one where the state provided a quality education so no one would have to endure the rejection, enforced religion and elitism of private schools. I’m not sure private schools should catch the students public schools cannot, but I also cannot advocate for keeping things as they are. PASS might fail our students, but so will doing nothing at all.

Adriana E. Ramírez, author of “Dead Boys,” is a columnist and InReview editor for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette. Her previous column was “But where are you REALLY from?” Find her on X: @zadri.