Driving up Forbes Avenue in Oakland yesterday, I spotted one of Lamar Advertising’s electronic billboards announcing “Sudden Little Thrills,” a two-day music festival in September.
While sitting in traffic in my car, as I coincidentally blasted some Wiz Khalifa, I couldn’t help but laugh; days earlier, Sudden Little Thrills was unceremoniously canceled. But the advertisements remain.
The 4-year-old in the backseat was confused, “What’s so funny, mama?”
“See that sign,” I pointed it out to her. “It wants us to go to a concert that isn’t real.”
“That is silly!” she said and laughed with me.
It was silly. But so was the fate of Sudden Little Thrills.
What does our city want?
A few weeks ago, I wrote about how excited I was to have a good music festival in town. I had some doubts, sure, but I didn’t vocalize them. While a lot of people I knew expressed concern about the location and lack of input from local promoters, I figured that the team behind Lollapalooza and Bonnaroo had the experience to pull this off.
Khalifa, SZA and The Killers were announced as the headliners, with many other smaller artists, DJs and bands bridging any gaps in appeal. In most cities, a lineup like this would be a slam dunk.
I certainly didn’t think that only 36 days after the festival was announced, it would be canceled.
“We were excited to bring a new world-class music festival to Pittsburgh, however, due to circumstances beyond our control, the Sudden Little Thrills Festival will not take place in 2024,” the website announced.
Why sports but not Beyoncé?
Was Sudden Little Thrills doomed from the beginning?
“I would give my left eye that it was ticket sales,” a local DJ messaged me on social media. “The date — football season. The location — a traffic nightmare. The lineup — two Black headliners? In Pittsburgh? Only $50 cheaper than Lollapalooza, but in a city without reliable public transit? Girl — this was a disaster from the beginning. This was our Fyre Festival.”
“The name was also terrible,” a local musician messaged me. “It sounded like a 70’s art-house [adult film]. Some woman discovers the joy in tiny things, etc.”
Jokes aside, the loss of this festival will be felt. As previously calculated, the economic impact alone would have been a boon for our city. Without it, we have to question what it is the people of Pittsburgh really want.
The Richard King Mellon Foundation, the Heinz Endowment and the Claude Worthington Benedum Foundation noted in a statement, “Pittsburgh has a proven track record of successfully hosting nationally headlining concerts, and we will continue bringing live performances and events to Hazelwood Green.”
But as a friend pointed out to me, how is it that a city where Taylor Swift and Kenny Chesney sellout shows, and where people pay hundreds of dollars for tickets for sports events, is a city where Beyoncé and Sudden Little Thrills cannot sell enough tickets?
A city that can host big deal shows suddenly can’t get it together for a music festival that would not only help our city’s finances, but would further establish Pittsburgh as a cultural destination?
What we could have had
What happened? I spoke to several people who wanted to buy tickets, but found them overpriced. Others who were waiting to save up a little money. More than one person indicated that there needed to be more time between announcing the show and selling tickets.
“How was I supposed to save up? They announced it, tried to sell tickets, and canceled it before more than one paycheck even went by,” someone wrote me. Pittsburgh’s lack of a financially-healthy Black middle class came up again and again.
Still — local musicians say that a lack of local promoters was part of the issue. That it was too many out-of-town people trying to call the shots. But others point out that that has little to do with out-of-town sales, which is what everyone, especially Visit Pittsburgh, was hoping for.
“If I’m flying for a concert,” one person said, “I’d rather go to Chicago.”
Several people messaged me to say that the Pittsburgh area likes country and classic rock, or more white-skewed music. “Wiz can sell out [The Pavilion at Star Lake], but not a whole festival in Hazelwood,” one person wrote.
It’s a shame, really. But perhaps it won’t be the end of talk of a big-deal music festival in Pittsburgh. For now, as many musicians and DJs have suggested, we should focus on supporting the festivals and concerts we do have.
But I cannot help but be sad at what could have been, at what we could have had — if only it had all been done differently.
I asked the friend who works in advertising why the electronic billboards are still up, given how canceled the festival remains.
“If they paid for a cycle of advertising, they paid for it. It’s not the advertising company’s fault that the festival didn’t make it 45 days.”
Or as my daughter put it, “That’s so silly, a sign for a thing that isn’t real. Unicorns also aren’t real. There should be more unicorn signs.”
Indeed.
Adriana E. Ramírez, author of “Dead Boys,” is a columnist and InReview editor for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette. Her previous column was “Why is Russia out of Eurovision, and Israel in?” Find her on X @zadri.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.