The Eurovision Song Contest is meant to be an apolitical celebration of music, artistry, collaboration and efficiency. The show began in 1956 and has symbolized the hopes and dreams of the post-war continent for a united Europe.
With 50 countries occupying a space roughly the size of Brazil, the continent is destined for conflict. And so the Eurovision Song Contest has done its best to define itself as being above war, running continuously throughout many intra-European conflicts.
Every country in the European Broadcasting Union’s Eurovision Network is allowed to participate in the contest. For that reason alone, the group includes Georgia, Azerbaijan, Armenia, Australia — and Israel.
So yes, that means Israel sent a delegation to Malmö, Sweden, and an apolitical organization found itself giving a platform to a regime credibly accused of killing over 8,000 children, as reported by Fox News (Other news organizations report a much higher number).
Complicity or joy?
Was the Eurovision Song Contest complicit in Israel’s crimes? Or was it simply doing what it has always done: put the joy of song over politics and war? Either way, the crowds came — some to cheer for the acts within, and others to protest outside.
Protestors carried a banner welcoming everyone to the “Genocide Song Contest.” Greta Thunberg was arrested, proudly wearing a keffiyeh and demanding a free Palestine.
The conflict also affected the contest within. The Dutch representative, who had been pointedly rude to the Israeli delegation, was disqualified for violating other rules of the contest. Rumors abounded on Reddit and in news publications across Europe that the network dropped him in retaliation for his anti-Israeli attitude.

Eden Golan, the 20-year-old Israeli singing “Hurricane,” originally titled “October Rain,” did her best. She smiled and waved, sang her song competently, and scored a counter-protest swell of support from the voting public, catapulting her into a fifth place finish that many called undeserved.
As someone who was pulling for both Nemo, the non-binary Swiss contestant who deservedly won with a song that contained both a rap interlude and arias sung in a full soprano, and Italy’s Angelina Mango, who brought an indifferently sexy cumbia about boredom, I was both annoyed at Golan’s surge in the voting and unconcerned. Sometimes being unpopular inspires a different form of popularity.
In order to retain its apolitical status, the EBU has to occasionally stoop to hypocrisy. It’s the nature of the beast, I suppose, but it still brings up difficult questions — like how the EBU reconciles its treatment of Israel with its treatment of Russia.
Russia out, Israel in
After Russia’s 2014 “annexation” of Crimea, the nation was still allowed to participate. In response to Russia’s unpopularity, during the 2015 contest, the EBU introduced “anti-booing technology,” which is effectively AI that detects crowd boos and instead replaces those sounds with excited applause and whistling.
This meant that for the viewing public, the Russian seemed to be invigorating the audience, whipping them into ecstatic fervor. Social media revealed a less than celebratory mood inside the building.
Russia wasn’t in Malmö this year and hasn’t been since 2022, after several EBU members protested its invasion of Ukraine. Its ally Belarus was banned the year before, for submitting songs with lyrics the EBU felt were political.
There is an irony to a broadcasting organization manipulating live television in order to remain “apolitical,” but it’s hard to hear over the sound of primary sponsor and Israeli-owned Moroccan Oil’s money being counted at EBU headquarters. Why else would Israel remain in the apolitical contest, after invading Gaza, as Russia had invaded Ukraine?
But don’t worry, Eurovision is not political, OK? It’s a song contest where any mention of Palestine or the Palestinian flag was banned, where the Portuguese contestant’s official performance video was initially pulled due to her fingernails having a “keffiyeh-inspired pattern” and where the Dutch didn’t even send a member of the jury to announce their points in protest of both Israel and the treatment of their representative, the very disqualified Joost Klein, whose song, ironically, was about the dream of a united Europe.
Turns out the one thing that really unites Europeans is hating Israel. Because as the poor 20-year-old sang her heart out about the weather, the “anti-booing technology” was in full effect. The computer-generated applause and whistles were deafening.
Apolitical politics
I love Eurovision. But the political choices the EBU makes in the effort to remain apolitical are hard to ignore.
The protestors outside Eurovision are trying to stop the deaths of tens of thousands of civilians. Many people watching and voting at home believe in Israel’s right to kill or be killed and demonstrated it by supporting the young Israeli woman. Nevertheless, the EBU persisted with its apolitical message in a world where being apolitical is proving to be increasingly impossible.
Whatever the EBU says, it cannot help but be political. Still, it’s about more than politics, right? I watch. So do millions. Because even as Greta Thunberg was being arrested outside, the Ukrainian delegation’s song made me cry and dance at the same time.
Which is what Eurovision, at its best, is supposed to be about.
Adriana E. Ramírez, author of “Dead Boys,” is a columnist and InReview editor for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette. Her previous column was “Our universities have become corporate spas with high-priced execs.” Find her on X @zadri.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.