“This is our Vietnam,” the 20-year old said to me in Schenley Plaza last Wednesday. “This is our time to let the powers that be know who we are and what we stand for.” She spoke for a minute about her Baby Boomer grandfather and the stories he had shared with her about protest culture in the late 1960s and early 1970s.
“We are doing exactly what our grandparents taught us to do. We are reclaiming Power to the People.”
I avoided getting into a history argument with a 20-year-old undergraduate, both because I’m sure she knew things that I did not, being actively in school, and because I saw no point in unpacking the differences between the U.S.’s role in Vietnam and in Israel.
Dissociating from Israel
She wouldn’t tell me her name, nor did I expect her to (“I’d prefer not to be doxxed by the internet, thank-you-very-much”), but I did watch her do her best for about half an hour to engage bystanders with the arguments underpinning her protest.
She, like most of the other students protesting on Pitt’s campus, wants the university to divest from any companies or investments associated with Israel.
“I think they want Pitt’s hedge fund managers to sell their Google and Airbnb stock?” a passing student said to me after speaking with the 20-year-old. “That seems easy enough. There’s lots of different stocks the university can invest in that don’t fund genocide.”
Final exams are over on Pitt’s campus, and the university is beginning to look sparse in the days leading up to graduation. Many of the non-graduating students have already left, having turned in their final papers and begun their summer jobs, internships and travels.
Unlike protestors at different universities, who still have classes in session, the protestors at Pitt find themselves making appeals to an ever-thinning crowd. But that hasn’t diminished the spirit of the camp — colorful tents surrounded by an increasing number of tiny Palestinian flags, some with the names of the dead written on them.
Down Forbes Avenue, closer to Craig Street, I ran into a small group of students non-confrontationally chanting “Jews for Palestine/Ceasefire Now.”
A shifting tide
The tide of opinion is shifting on Israel, as the toll of war moves from inevitable civilian casualties into the realm of active eradication. While some people still hold to the belief that Israel is in a kill-or-be-killed scenario, many people believe, and insist, that the nation has other viable options than the one it’s chosen.
To these activists, any action that pressures Israel into a ceasefire is good. Even if it means camping out on campus so that the university’s hedge fund manager might take notice. I’m sure some financial planners are preparing a “Student-Protest-Proof” portfolio for their university clients, but one investment expert I spoke to told me that was pretty impossible.
“Today it will be ‘divest in Israel,’ but tomorrow it might be ‘divest in some other place,’ and there’s no way to predict the ethical behaviors of countries where any given multinational corporation does business.”
“But I like these kids, they have moxie.”
The Pitt protests have not turned violent, unlike others around the country. A university spokesperson noted to various media outlets that they stand behind the students’ rights to protest, and when Pitt asked the protestors to leave the Cathedral of Learning’s lawn and use Schenley Plaza as a site, the campers did so willingly.
The university, the police and the city have worked out a timeline for the campsite’s removal, before various commencement ceremonies take place this weekend.
Protest organizer Cameryn Gray told WTAE that “we are going to hold the space, we are going to occupy the space,” until “as a coalition and community we are going to decide what the safest and most ethical practice should be for us,” before confirming that they would adhere to the plan.
Unlike protestors at Columbia, Pitt students have not drawn significant counter-protestors yet. Some people yelled at and booed me, not for being a journalist, a woman of color or a Jew (chag sameach!), but for working for the Post-Gazette.
Saving lives
There were enough Jewish kids around, all safe and at least half of them participating in the protest, that only someone on another planet could declare it antisemitic. The atmosphere seemed close to a music festival.
These kids seemed intelligent and well-informed. They were passionate and really thought they could save lives with their protest.
I left Schenley Plaza more hopeful than I arrived. The kids, at least the kids in Pittsburgh, are alright, The Who might say.
I know this is not true of all the protests around the country. But here, in the Steel City, we seem to be made of firmer stuff.
Adriana E. Ramírez, author of “Dead Boys,” is a columnist and InReview editor for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette. Her previous column was “When writers fight other writers about fighting for writers.” Find her on X @zadri.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.