I was on my honeymoon in Jamaica when I learned that I was just honored with the PEN/Fusion Emerging Writers Prize for a series of essays called “Dead Boys.” Within a few months, I acquired an amazing agent, who then sold my book at auction, and helped establish my career path. I owe PEN America a lot.

On Friday night, I announced one of the winners at the Los Angeles Times Book Prizes. As I made my way to the stage, the host mentioned my PEN award and I heard a little titter from one part of the audience.

“You should have disavowed PEN. You had a platform,” a woman told me at the afterparty. “They’re pretty much the bad guys these days.”

How did a literary organization that exists to “protect free expression,” is currently actively fighting book bans and does tremendous work to advocate for writers, end up as the “bad guys”?

Advertise with us

How PEN became the bad guys

The answer, of course, is the war between Israel and Hamas, and the larger question of Palestinian suffering. Over a thousand writers signed a letter in March, lambasting the organization for “[betraying] the organization’s professed commitment to peace and equality for all, and to freedom and security for writers everywhere.”

As Literary Hub noted, “The letter goes on to detail the various ways in which PEN America has failed Palestinian writers and journalists — as well as their allies in the United States — since the beginning of Israel’s war on Gaza,” and rebukes the organization for choosing not “to join other leading human rights organizations and United Nations officials in the demands for an immediate and unconditional ceasefire.”

After over a third of the nominees for the 2024 PEN America Literary Awards withdrew, the organization was forced to cancel this year’s ceremony. The PEN America World Voices Festival will continue in May, albeit with a much-reduced lineup of authors.

But should PEN America have called for a ceasefire? The organization, while a lobbyist for free speech, is not an advocacy organization for other political causes. It supports the writing of everyone — including Palestinian writers and Zionist writers. Their goal is to foster free expression, especially when it’s not popular.

It’s why they are the organization at the front of the book battles. PEN America believes that “people everywhere have the freedom to create literature, to convey information and ideas, to express their views, and to access the views, ideas, and literatures of others.”

Advertise with us

That means defending the right of pro-Israeli writers as much as it is defending the right of those subject to genocide. It’s a complicated stance, one that’s full of nuance at a time when nuance is no longer welcome.

What PEN didn’t do

I understand the over 1300 writers who signed on to protest PEN America. It feels impossible to stand aside when people are being killed, when hospitals are being blown up, when war and all its fallout produces harrowing images of dead children.

I completely get why so many writers believe that PEN America should have been leading the charge against war crimes. Important organizations calling for a ceasefire puts pressure on the government. Calling for divestment and boycotts offers ordinary people an effective way to affect global politics.

The heart of the protestors is not in the wrong place. I’m just not sure that PEN America is the enemy.

PEN America advocates for the writer recently removed from Guernica Magazine for writing an article about living in Israel during the conflict that was widely, though wrongly, perceived as pro-Israel. They are also advocating for USC’s valedictorian, Asna Tabassum, whose speech was canceled over her pro-Palestinian views.

Advertise with us

The organization does support peace, for the record, calling “for an immediate ceasefire and release of the hostages — an agreement that can pave the way for urgent humanitarian access and lasting peace,” according to a statement on their website.

But in parts of the writing community, it’s perceived as too little, too late, too “both sides,” when for many poets, essayists and novelists, those sides feel morally distinct.

“PEN America should have been leading the charge against genocide,” I was told repeatedly during the festival, as outside, a group of peaceful protestors chanted “Free Palestine.”

The good PEN does do

Another author, who is both a big deal and refused to be named in this piece, had a different take. “Look,” he noted over coffee, “PEN America does more good than harm. The fight over libraries and books, their commitment to letting everyone have their say … it’s hard to find that right now.”

He lamented that the literary world was so fractured over this, that so many writers are remaining silent instead of expressing themselves. He lamented this most of all.

Advertise with us

“We don’t want to dismantle PEN America, but if the loudest voices in the room get their way, we’re going to throw out the baby with the bathwater,” he said. “And then who will be left to fight for us?”

Adriana E. Ramírez, author of “Dead Boys,” is a columnist and InReview editor for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette. Find her on X @zadri. Her previous column was “Don’t worry about the Democrats who won’t vote for Joe Biden.”