Like so many other Jewish families I know, my family has been caught in the middle of complicated conversations about the intersection of our faith and global politics.
We are staunchly anti-genocide. We are committed to a ceasefire. We know that supporting a ceasefire is not inherently anti-Jewish. We are also troubled by the upswing in casual antisemitism we witness every day.
These positions should not be in conflict with one another. But a quick look across the local political landscape says otherwise: Pittsburgh has divided itself into pro-Palestinian and pro-Jewish camps on the issue of the war in Gaza, without realizing that those views are not necessarily mutually exclusive.
Unwarranted and understandable
I wish I could say it was easy for me to condemn Israel’s actions, and know that I do. But as much as I abhor their genocidal tactics and murdering of civilians, I understand the violent history and pain that has engendered this outlandish response — a history and pain not necessarily of their making.
On Oct. 7, my husband said as much: “Israel will do everything in the power to make Hamas, and anyone remotely associated with Hamas, feel their wrath.” There was no pride in his statement, only grief for the innocents of Palestine.
However I may feel about a people or their beliefs, I have to believe in their ability to exist, to self-determine, to be free. It is, perhaps ironically, a core tenet of my faith.
Read More
And in the face of a response that is both unwarranted and understandable, there is so little we can do. At the local level, asking the county to pass a resolution made sense to some and no sense to others.
As other cities and municipalities join together in calling for a ceasefire, pressure mounts on the national government to follow through and ask for a pause in hostilities in the name of humanitarian aid. Getting Allegheny County to follow suit felt like something people could accomplish. But to others, it felt unnecessary.
And the words and actions of some, perhaps only a few, pro-ceasefire activists felt offensive enough for many Jewish leaders in the city of Pittsburgh to oppose their language and the resolution. The rhetoric felt antisemitic, problematic and dangerous for a city that was still mourning the lives lost in the synagogue shooting of 2018.
At a contentious county council meeting last Tuesday, it became clear that people on both sides of the issue are frustrated with what little they can do. More than 200 people spoke, with about 137 expressing the desire for Allegheny County Council to pass a resolution urging the federal government to pursue a cease-fire. One supporter of the resolution declared that opposing the resolution was supporting genocide.
The 70 people who spoke against the resolution prevailed. Some believed that to support a cease-fire was to support Hamas. Some felt that it would be pointless. Others thought it would increase divisions and acts of antisemitism.
The insults flew. When councilmembers tried to explain their votes, they were met with derision. Every, “How can one be against genocide but also against a resolution condemning genocide?” was met with “How could anyone support a ceasefire against terrorists?” Conversations sailed past one another.
Jewish and anti-Zionist
As I watched clips, I got a text from a friend who was there. “Someone just got kicked out and couldn’t believe we were being asked to be calm in the face of state-sanctioned murder — and then we talked about local property assessments.”
When I spoke to her on the phone later, we talked about the rabbis who stood up to talk at the meeting. After a minute, I found myself defending my rabbi, who had recently signed a letter denouncing Rep. Summer Lee.
I did not want to defend my rabbi’s stance, as I wasn’t sure whether or not I agreed with the letter or with Ms. Lee’s actions, but the way the conversation went, I suddenly felt attacked for being Jewish — and expressed as much. I knew my friend wasn’t being antisemitic, but we danced as close to the line as we could while remaining friends.
She called me again this morning, and we both apologized.
“It’s nuts how quickly I turned against you, when I love you,” she said.
I agreed. We’d never exchanged a cross word before.
“You know,” I repeated for the one millionth time since last October, “being Jewish is not being pro-Zionist.”
In The New Republic, Aaron Gell points out that a growing number of young Jewish Americans “are showing a newfound willingness to publicly question — and sometimes to loudly condemn — the very idea of a Jewish state.” The anti-Zionist Jewish movement is strong.
But the truth is that anti-Zionist Jews are in the minority. Most Jewish Americans support Israel, as Mr. Gell notes, for two good reasons: “The Shoah, which convinced many Jews that they could never again entrust their welfare to a non-Jewish majority; and a remarkably effective effort by the Zionist establishment to weave the nation-state project into the fabric of Jewish life.”
For most Jews, to be Jewish is to support Israel, which means the converse is true as well — to not support Israel is to not support the Jewish people. The two are utterly intertwined, and so the rhetoric of freeing Palestine feels inherently antisemitic. How can it not be?
It all feels precarious
This all feels so precarious. I wish to assert the right of Israel to both exist and defend itself while condemning the scale and scope of their actions. But that line feels too nuanced for the present.
At a writer’s conference a few weeks ago, I joked with a fellow Jewish poet that nuance is for historians looking back on this from the future. He looked at me like I was on a different planet. He was probably right.
“How can you be talking about nuance when people are dying?”’
“Exactly,” I replied.
Adriana E. Ramírez, author of “Dead Boys,” is a columnist and InReview editor for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette. Her previous column was “The world’s water crisis is coming to Pittsburgh.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.