Legacy is a tricky business — after all, we have little to no control over how the world sees us after our death. We cannot dictate how we will be remembered or even if our works on this earth will be recollected. How those that remain engage with what we bequeath to the world is beyond our understanding, and certainly beyond our jurisdiction.
Flannery O’Connor, beloved short story writer and doyenne of the literary South, left behind a tremendous legacy, given her thirty-nine years of life. Yet — in the sixty years since she died, her work has been constantly revisited, re-examined and re-litigated. She has been long deceased, but her legacy continues to be redefined.
Racist language
O’Connor exists in the American literary imagination as a master of craft, as well as a controversial figure of her time. She grew up in the Jim Crow South. She once refused to meet James Baldwin in Georgia. She used the n-word in her correspondence and short stories.
Her deployment of racist language caused students at Loyola University Maryland to successfully petition to rename the Flannery O’Connor Residence Hall on campus in 2020. And although priests at the university advocated for the nuance in O’Connor’s work, she was deemed worthy of removal.

I like to think that O’Connor would have shrugged off the criticism. Her correspondence reveals someone who was invested deeply in the reality of her time. We cannot speculate as to how she would feel about Black people today, but we do have windows into how she felt about racist language.
When, at a party in Iowa, she was told by a fellow writer to not use pejorative language in her stories, O’Connor balked. She firmly believed that she had to write as the people actually spoke, and where she grew up, no one would even consider using different terminology.
“The truth doesn’t change according to your ability to stomach it,” O’Connor wrote to a friend in a letter about the conversation. “A higher paradox confounds the emotion as well as reason and there are long periods in the lives of all of us, when the truth as revealed by faith is hideous, emotionally disturbing, downright repulsive.”
Damn. The woman could write. Was she racist? Probably not, but maybe a little. Was she problematic? Of course. She was an artist, and art that is safe is rarely worthy of scrutiny. Is she worth of our intense obsession? Yes, most definitely. Her talent is undisputed — as is her place in the American canon of literature.
The complexity of grace
And now, she has a new book out — sorta. Flannery O’Connor’s unfinished novel, “Why Do The Heathen Rage?” has been released, as a work-in-progress, by Brazos Press, along with a deep “literary excavation” by Jessica Hooten Wilson, an O’Connor scholar. Wilson provides commentary and context on the incomplete work, publishing O’Connor’s unrevised words while acknowledging the impossibility of knowing what the finished product could have been.
An author’s work is never done, it would seem. Unfinished books by Michael Crichton, Jack London and Charles Dickens were published posthumously, doing their best to take advantage of a market eager to consume the dead.
In this regard, Wilson saves O’Connor from the most voracious of the literary vampires. She makes no attempt to finish what O’Connor left undone, but she does give those who revere the Southern gothic writer enough to chew on.
“Why Do the Heathen Rage?” contains fragments of many other O’Connor classics. The unfinished novel reminds us of O’Connor’s incredible talent, as well as her intensely Catholic view of the universe, while staying true to the complexity of grace in a world that can seem devoid of such things.
Like in her many other works, as noted by Jesuit priest and former president of Loyola University Maryland Father Brian Linnane, “the dignity of African American persons and their worth is consistently upheld, with the bigots being the object of ridicule.” But the Black people in “Why Do the Heathen Rage?” are still subject to the realities of the post-slavery Jim Crow South, something O’Connor reproduces unflinchingly.
Taught and questioned
In revealing the idiocy of racism, O’Connor had to depict the violence and insidiousness of racism too. She had to perpetuate and reify that which she was undermining. There is an inherent tension to this, one that will constantly threaten her legacy — as it should.
Our thoughts about O’Connor can be messy, can be contradictory: She should be taught, and she should be questioned. Our opinions can remain unfinished, couched in context and constantly swirling with nuance. To love her is also to see her for what she is and know that her legacy, like that of many others, is complicated.
As O’Connor herself wrote, “I hope that to be of two minds about some things is not to be neutral.”
Adriana E. Ramírez, author of “Dead Boys,” is a columnist and InReview editor for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette. Find her on X @zadri.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.