I am not a big fan of deer. I often call them “rats with long legs.” I am probably the only person who is not sad when she watches “Bambi.” Children will be sobbing at Bambi’s mother’s death, and I will sit there enumerating all the diseases deer carry.
Deer-borne ticks, I often remind my husband (who finds deer cute), ended up giving a beloved pet Lyme disease years ago. Urban deer trotted up to our front porch and ate our jack-o-lanterns a few Halloweens back.
And once, driving along a rural Pennsylvania highway at night, a deer carcass another car had hit flew onto my windshield, damaging my little hatchback so badly that the insurance company deemed it a total loss. I blamed the deer for years.
They are everywhere
Erika Howsare’s well-researched book “The Age of Deer” aims to correct such perceptions, or at the very least, to complicate them. Howsare, a poet by training, lyrically explores the relationship between man and deer — from thousands-and-thousands year old cave paintings in Europe to a Western Pa. deer hunt in the present — and the result is a compelling and thorough account of our relationship to the planet’s most ubiquitous ruminant.
For Howsare, who grew up just south of Pittsburgh, our relationship to deer exposes our relationship with nature. Deer are creatures of the deep forest and denizens of urban areas. “Although we conceive of cities as being animal-free, they are in fact teeming with animal life,” she notes.
Deer really are everywhere. They are native to every continent except Antarctica (for obvious reasons) and Australia (due to isolation). But these days, even Australia boasts a deer population in the millions — a destructive invasive species without a natural place in the ecosystem.
Hunters cannot keep pace, and there are no natural predators to cull their ever-expanding numbers. There were non-human apex predators in the United States once — wolves, bears, coyotes, wild cats, foxes, etc. — but as we’ve killed or driven those predators away, we now depend on ourselves to hunt the almost forty million deer in America.
And sportsmen cannot catch up. As Howsare notes, nearly six million deer are hunted each year and a couple million are killed by vehicles (another apex predator of sorts). The rest are free to eat carved pumpkins on porches and back yards across the country.
We tell stories about them
Deer roam our forests, highways, and parks. They also roam our imagination. We all have stories about deer. We must. We’re humans, and humans have always been surrounded by deer.
Mythologically and historically, deer have dominated art — from abstract sketches to realistic interpretations of forest-life, as well as the aforementioned cave paintings. I’ve seen far too many films, and read far too many short stories, that have used deer as a metaphor for purity, nature, and wilderness. (The “der” in wilderness, Howsare points out, comes from “deer.”)
Deer connect us to our ancestors. Over the centuries, almost every culture has eaten venison, worn buckskin, and hung antlers on walls. Deer might be the one thing all humans have always had in common.
Deer can be our teachers, Howsare asserts: “Adaptation is fundamental to life on earth, but some species are better at it than others. Many deer species happen to be very good at it … they have proven brilliantly able to remake their way of life — to reinvent what it means to be a deer.”
Deer, she continues: “are Anthropocene heroes. They are mashup-makers, remixers, shape-shifters, contemporary masters of disguise. What animal could be a more perfect emblem for our own selves? Our precarious, fluctuating state?”
I want to say that “The Age of Deer” made me love the creatures, but it didn’t. I still think of them as long-legged vessels of disease. But Erika Howsare made me respect deer and the way their history intertwines with our own.
It’s not their fault
It’s not their fault that they carry disease. It’s not their fault that they haven’t evolved to understand how cars will hit them. It’s not their fault that they’ve been genetically programmed to eat our hostas.
It’s not the deer’s fault that venison is delicious.
We live in the age of deer, that’s certain. And in Howsare’s estimation, that only benefits us all. Even if it’s just with a good dinner.
Adriana E. Ramírez, author of “Dead Boys,” is a columnist and InReview editor for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette. Find her on X @zadri.
APPEARANCE: Erika Howsare will be reading from “The Age of Deer” at White Whale bookstore on Feb.10th at 7PM with nature writer Andrew Moore. More information and tickets are available via White Whale.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.