Of the 32 teams in the National Football League, only 20 have won Super Bowls. Only fifteen have won more than one and only ten can claim more than two. Only the New England Patriots and Pittsburgh Steelers have won six.
But that’s not enough for Pittsburgh. Nor should it be.
We enjoy being the best. We enjoy being a “city of champions — and home of the Pirates,” as my favorite t-shirt boasts. I wear my Steelers gear with pride, excited when I spot someone sporting the Black and Gold abroad or in an unexpected place (like a goth club in Miami!).
We want rings
Pittsburgh likes being a city of sports dominance. We want another ring; Pittsburgh wants all the rings. I cannot begrudge anyone the desire to win.
Under the tenure of Coach Mike Tomlin, the Pittsburgh Steelers have had seventeen winning seasons and one Super Bowl victory. He is arguably the best coach active in the NFL and definitely in the top three. Tomlin deserves his accolades. He is a player’s coach, beloved by the team and championed by them all. There’s a reason we’ve never heard a player badmouth Coach Tomlin. The man is a class act.
Still, the 2023-2024 season was rough. We fired offensive coordinator Matt Canada ten games into the season after looking pretty mediocre on the field for all of them. We lost key players to injury — including quarterback Kenny Pickett. We suffered through our Mitch Trubisky phase, as all storied teams must (see: the Chicago Bears).
As the season drew to an end, the cries to have Tomlin fired or replaced escalated locally — and the arguments were loud: We have only won three playoff games in ten years. We don’t look like the 2006 or 2009 or 1970s Steelers. We should be contenders for the national championship instead of perennially sidelined could-have-beens. What good are a million winning seasons if we can’t win when it really matters?
Millions of words were written and uttered in speculation over Tomlin’s future. All this before a single official word from the Steelers, the Rooney Family or Tomlin himself.
It was enough to finally piss him off.
And so he walked away during a press conference, after being asked the question again. As if this time, he’d have a different answer. As if this time, he’d finally let everyone in on his negotiation strategy. As if he owed anyone insight into his career decisions. As if every other team in the NFL wouldn’t be happy to have him.
The next day, he made it clear that he planned to coach the team through another extension. The day after that, the Rooney Family confirmed it as well. It didn’t matter. Criticism on social media remained relentless.
An Oilers fan knows
I grew up in Texas, an Oilers fan until they didn’t exist anymore. The Oilers never won a Super Bowl. The closest they got to the big game was the AFC championship, which they played in both the 1978 and 1979 seasons. Both times they were defeated by the Pittsburgh Steelers.
But as an Oilers fan in the 1980s and 1990s, I never knew a winning team. The Oilers became the Tennessee Titans — who have also never won a Super Bowl. A friend of mine from Nashville messaged me last week to ask if Tomlin was really leaving “and do you think the Titans could hire him? They need someone like him.”
Someone like Mike Tomlin is rare. After the firing of Matt Canada, the Steelers went on to win four of the next seven games, a statistical improbability, finishing the season 10-7. We then managed to move all the planets and stars in our favor, because we snuck into the playoffs on nothing more than a wish. We faced the Buffalo Bills, the number two seed with both homefield advantage and a healthy starting quarterback.
The Bills game was closer than it should have been. At one point, we were one score from a tie. There were some questionable calls by the referees. The wind was against us. T.J. Watt was out. And still, we made it a game, when by all odds and reason after that first half, we should have been grateful for mercy.
Part of it was the ascent of Mason Rudolph (we affectionately call him “Red-nose” in my house), who played like his career in the NFL depended on it — and it did.
But most of the credit for what we were able to accomplish, despite very little going our way, goes to Tomlin. He made something out of nothing. And we’re so spoiled when it comes to football that we don’t get how amazing and rare that is in a league with so few repeat winners.
There are only four teams in the NFL that have not been to the Super Bowl: The Cleveland Browns, Jacksonville Jaguars, Detroit Lions and Houston Texans. The Lions and Texans remain in the playoffs, two games away from changing their franchises’ history, but the odds of both making it to the big game are slim.
We forget how good we have it, when it comes to the Steelers. My dad, forever a Houston fan, thinks that people in Pittsburgh are ridiculous. He’s proud of his no-Super-Bowls team, even though they were pretty terrible for most of their existence.
My dad is also an inductee of the Texas Rugby Hall of Fame as a coach, and he sees the value in Coach Tomlin. “You have to look at the big picture,” he said to me. “And the big picture is that Tomlin is an incredible coach.”
The great numbers
Maybe it’s Coach Tomlin’s fault. He’s set such a high expectation that when he fails to live up to it, we cannot help but hold him accountable. But the numbers don’t lie: He has higher winning percentages than Bill Cowher or Chuck Noll, both of whom had losing seasons and occasionally missed the playoffs.
And there’s something to be said for the stability Tomlin has brought to the franchise.
But still, it’s not enough. We will always want more. Even if we already have the best.
We don’t deserve Mike Tomlin. But no fan really deserves anything. We can only hope our team wins next year. And hopefully, Mike Tomlin knows that this too is part of the game.
Adriana E. Ramírez, author of “Dead Boys,” is a columnist and InReview editor for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette: aramirez@post-gazette.com.
Correction: A previous version of this column misstated the extent of the questions address to Tomlin directly about his future with Pittsburgh.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.