A man sits on a barstool in Amsterdam’s red light district and confesses his fall from grace, from upstanding lawyer to loquacious carouser, from a believer in goodness to a proponent of sin.

He tells the story of a night when he walked away from a girl standing by a bridge and soon heard the splash of someone hitting the water and the scream of someone dying — probably the young woman he just saw. He chooses, after a long deliberative pause, to keep walking.

Readers taken in

Albert Camus’ novel “The Fall” works because even as the narrator tells the terrible things he has done, his charm shines through. The reader is taken in by Jean-Baptiste Clamence’s language, his intelligence and his desire to interrogate the nature of his own being.

Advertise with us

Later, when his sense of self and career collapse, Clamence considers the moment by the bridge, concluding that he wished he could say: “O young girl, throw yourself again into the water so that I might have a second time the chance to save the two of us!” But suppose, he continues, “someone actually took our word for it? It would have to be fulfilled. Brr...! the water is so cold! But let’s reassure ourselves. It’s too late now, it will always be too late. Fortunately!”

Camus argues that for all our purported moral rectitude, we are selfish creatures who demand recognition. We will always choose popularity, even when we try to be selfless. That’s why his narrator doffs his hat after helping a blind man cross the street: He wants to be acknowledged by someone, even if it’s not the man he helped. He wants to be seen.

And he’s charming about it. We can see ourselves in Clamence, as he faces the same moral dilemmas we might  encounter in the real world. How many of us would jump in after we heard the splash in the water? I hope that most of us would, but I would also be thinking about the cold water.

We want to privately root for bad boys, while embracing that they’re jerks. That’s the appeal of the Clamences of the world. But, sadly, not of Elliot Chase.

Morally dubious narrators

Advertise with us

Alex Michaelides’ newest novel, “The Fury” (Celadon Books, $38.99), is the story of seven people trapped on an island, one of them murdered and one of them the murderer — and it also has a morally dubious narrator.

Elliot Chase, a playwright named after a volatile Noël Coward character, lacks the charm of Clamence, though, which makes him slightly insufferable as a narrator. Elliot’s character feels more like an amalgam of several other protagonists; he is part Jean-Baptiste Clamence, part “Talented Mr. Ripley,” part “American Psycho’s” Patrick Bateman and part Nabokov’s Humbert Humbert — a who’s who of literary bad boys, but without their appeal and with perhaps far too much writerly self-awareness.

If character is destiny, as Mr. Michaelides asserts, Elliot is destined for comeuppance. Other characters remark on Elliot’s unlikability, on what a jerk and smug person he is. “Oh,” the reader might think, “they’re right.” I’m not going to lie, I spent most of the novel really hoping that Elliot would be replaced as the narrator.

Elliot is worthy of scrutiny, though. He is friends with movie stars, temperamental stage actresses and novelists, and hails from a humble background. But his self-awareness as a writer and lack of relatable humor deprive the reader of the joy that comes with the unlikeable protagonist: secretly rooting for his success.

“The Fury’’ is well-plotted — a murder mystery in the style of “Knives Out” with the sensibilities of “Hamlet” (“the play’s the thing!”) and “Rebecca” woven-in to great effect. There’s adultery, drugs and a mysterious groundskeeper. What’s not to like!?

Advertise with us

But perhaps it has too many references, too many Easter eggs, too many hollow allusions that illuminate nothing, all coupled with stories we already know. It’s almost as if Mr. Michaelides was afraid to be original.

“The Fury” will be a success, no doubt, and I’m sure one day a film as well. I’m excited to see someone bring life to Elliot.

An amazing character

But I cannot help but consider the novel that “The Fury” could have been. “The Great Gatsby’’ would not have worked if Gatsby himself had been the narrator. We need Nick to tell the story, because the allure of Gatsby is his mystery, what he provokes in others.

Elliot Chase has all the trappings of an amazing character — he is perpetually humiliated and persistently evasive, power-hungry and star-obsessed. “The Fury” could have been more, if only Elliot hadn’t been the only one to tell his story.

Advertise with us

But let’s reassure ourselves. It’s too late now, it will always be too late. Fortunately!

Adriana E. Ramírez, author of “Dead Boys,” is a columnist and InReview editor for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette: aramirez@post-gazette.com.

APPEARANCE:

Alex Michaelides will be reading at Carnegie Library Lecture Hall on Thurs., January 18th at 6 p.m. More information and tickets are available via Pittsburgh Arts and Lectures.