Politics is the gift that keeps on giving. And this Christmas holiday, a bombshell ruling from Colorado will dominate dinner discussions around the world. Hooray for none of us.

The Supreme Court of Colorado declared Donald Trump ineligible for the presidency. The justices declared, in their 4-3 decision, that “the court holds that Trump is disqualified from holding the office of president under Section 3 of the 14th Amendment.”

Depending on your worldview and where you watch the news, this is either the best or the worst thing that has ever happened to American democracy.

Some believe that with this ruling, the courts have disenfranchised the people of Colorado. Voters should get to determine how eligible someone is, not the courts. A true democracy would not depend on the opinion of unelected justices.

Advertise with us

Others believe that the law does not exempt anyone. Even a former president. If the law says something is illegal, why should wealth and privilege exempt Mr. Trump from consequences? A true democracy would hold everyone equally accountable.

After all, Democrats are quick to point out, this lawsuit was initially brought by the nonpartisan Citizens for Responsibility and Ethics in Washington on behalf of a half-dozen Republican and independent voters.

But to Trump supporters, this merely proves their point: Of course Washington swamp creatures and RINOs want Trump off the ballot. It feels dirty to remove him this way.

Bad and good

I watched Jan. 6 on live television. I’d stayed home to watch C-SPAN, like one does, and saw events unfold in real time. It felt chaotic and organized at the same time, a riot and an insurrection, depending on the person, depending on the angle. Most importantly and objectively, though, it was a disruption of government, an attempt to undo the will of the people.

Advertise with us

It felt bad and unamerican — inevitable and also embarrassing. We were supposed to be better than this.

Jonathan Turley, a law professor at George Washington University, recently said on Fox News, “January 6 was many things, most of it not good.” But for him, it did not qualify as an insurrection.

“That doesn’t mean that the people responsible for that day shouldn’t be held accountable,” he added. “But to call this an insurrection for the purposes of disqualification would create a slippery slope for every state in the union.”

That’s where he loses me. I understand that we will never know the full actions and motivations of the participants. But Mr. Trump saw what I saw, what we all saw, and he thought, “This is good.”

He cheered it on. He set his own personal interests against the workings of American democracy.

Advertise with us

There’s a reason this clause of the 14th amendment is untested: No one has yet been awful enough to test it.

Wishful thinking

This happens so rarely that we don’t quite know for sure how to define simple words like “insurrection,” much to the delight of Merriam Webster’s technology team.

“Super,” a friend of mine bemoaned. “Now I’m going to spend Christmas just pointing to the dictionary app on my phone — it’s not my fault that words have meanings.”

But the meanings of words aren’t clear, especially when it comes to the law, or we wouldn’t be having these debates.

Advertise with us

“I hope [Chief Justice] Roberts can wrangle the court so that the decision is unanimous,” a colleague said. “Anything else would just look partisan.”

And he’s right. But that’s wishful thinking.

Some will say that no one is above the law. Some will say that democracy should not be in the hands of judges. They will both be right, they will both be wrong.

Hope beyond fear

When it comes to Mr. Trump, opinions abound. I cannot imagine anyone who could say “I don’t have an opinion one way or the other.” It’s exhausting. He’s either the Second Coming or the Anti-Christ, and during these holy days, it’s probably better we stop with the religious talk about a man who professes little to no faith in anything outside himself.

Advertise with us

There are already a thousand discussions happening in cubicle farms and in classrooms about whether or not Mr. Trump is responsible for inciting the events of Jan. 6, 2021. Of course, talking and thinking about him all the time is exactly what he wants.

Ultimately, against the doomsday preachers from all sides, I believe that our Constitution is strong enough to withstand whatever happens, as long as it’s done with prudence and forethought.

In the sci-fi version of our universe, a thousand simulations would run, playing out the consequences of every possibility. But our real world is not so predictable.

The only thing we can hope for is that calm and rational minds will prevail. And that the Supreme Court considers the Pandora’s Box that’s waiting for them under the Christmas tree with awe and trepidation.

Merry Christmas to us all. May we get what we need and not what we want. And may hope remain.

Advertise with us

Now what’s for dessert?

Adriana E. Ramírez, author of “Dead Boys,” is a columnist and InReview editor for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette: aramirez@post-gazette.com.