When I first moved to Pittsburgh, almost twenty years ago, I remember my first encounter with the Pittsburgh Left. At a traffic light in Squirrel Hill, I waited until the signal changed and then I began to accelerate. Suddenly, across the street, in the opposite direction, a car accelerated madly and crossed in front of me, cutting over to make a left turn.
“Wow,” I remember thinking, “that guy is a terrible driver.”
And then it happened again. In Shadyside, in Oakland, even in Allentown where I went to buy a used desk. People kept making this incredibly dangerous left turn in front of oncoming traffic.
On my first trip back home to Texas for the holidays, I remember my friends asking me if I liked Pittsburgh and my graduate school program. I nodded happily enough. And then a friend who had been to Pittsburgh before asked the most important question of all: “What do you think of the Pittsburgh Left?”
I had never heard the name before, but I immediately knew what he meant. “Oh, yes,” he still often quotes me as saying, “It’s fun to see people driving with a death wish.”
Old habits
Pittsburgh existed before cars. My friend Darius, who is a civil engineer, told me that most roads in the city of Pittsburgh were originally horse paths, commonly used trails that eventually became streets and roads.
Horse paths did not have to be wide. After all, a horse-drawn carriage, the widest vehicle of the day, didn’t take up too much space. Bridges were built on an as-needed basis, as were bigger roads, ones that connected different neighborhoods and towns as the city grew.
“Unlike most cities in the West, or in places like Texas,” Darius pointed out, “Pittsburgh had to carve out space for cars — which is the opposite of planned development. There is no grid.”
Which means that over time, certain habits evolved. The Pittsburgh Left emerged from the lack of turn signals, dedicated turn lanes, and practical necessity.
A car making a left turn has to wait for traffic to clear. The Pittsburgh Left, a sharp turn as soon as the light changes to green, allows those making a left to get out of the way. The problem, of course, is that it’s utterly dangerous. A driver unfamiliar with the Pittsburgh Left might accelerate at a green light, plowing directly into a left-turning vehicle.
And, as Steve Cowan from the Pennsylvania Department of Transportation points out, the Pittsburgh Left is also utterly illegal.
New signals
In other words, no matter how convenient it is for a car turning left to clear the lane, for our local government, the risk outweighs the reward. Any person being injured in a traffic accident can cause more delays, more headaches, and more traffic.
New traffic signals have begun appearing in the city. The Flashing Yellow Arrow (FYA) lights are timed in such a way that the green light for the opposing traffic turns on a few seconds before the flashing yellow arrow. Motorists going the opposite direction will be moving through the intersection before those turning left even have the opportunity to gun it. They have to wait for a space.
I asked Mr. Cowan if the new traffic signals in town were a corrective to the Pittsburgh Left. “The new installation of Flashing Yellow Arrow is actually not in response to any regionally-termed traffic patterns, like the Pittsburgh Left,” he said.
“The flashing yellow signal was approved by the Federal Highway Administration after nation-wide research showed the flashing yellow arrow heightens driver awareness when turning left in front of oncoming traffic.”
But the unintended consequences are not lost on most Pittsburgh motorists.
“They’re getting rid of the Pittsburgh Left,” a concerned driver from Penn Hills told me in line at Panera. “They put a traffic light on the Highland Park Bridge — a highway, mind you — and they’re doing their best to take away everything that makes driving in Pittsburgh fun.”
Not fun anymore
But the goal of driving is not to have fun. It’s to get from one place to another, in relative safety and speed. No matter how much new practices erode our old habits, it’s important we adjust to the change.
Take the Highland Park Bridge. The on-ramp from Aspinwall onto Highway 28 was dangerous on a good day without traffic. Firefighters in Sharpsburg, who declined to be identified, think the new traffic signal, on the bridge itself, has already saved lives.
“The commuters might complain,” one told me, “but as someone who has had to pull people out of vehicles there, I can tell you that it’s already a heck of a lot safer on that bridge. People were dying just to get home a little faster.”
PennDOT agrees. “The new traffic signal installation was warranted based on reviews of past crash history in addition to the shorter roadway section for merging traffic prior to PA 28 Northbound or Southbound ramps,” Mr. Cowan wrote. “Now that the traffic signal is installed, we’ll need time to evaluate the pre- and post-construction crash data results and operational benefits.”
At the Morningside Senior Citizen Center, the residents seemed overjoyed to have a signal on the bridge. “I know it might make some people upset to be stuck in traffic,” said a resident who wanted to be identified as Mary, “but for us, that signal has made it much easier to cross the river safely.”
Same traffic
“Who puts a light on a highway?” a man from New Kensington asked on an online forum. “My commute is now longer because a few people couldn’t figure out how to merge?”
As I drove home from the North Shore last week during rush-hour traffic, I noted the line of cars going back across the bridge and down into Washington Boulevard. I was glad to be driving in the opposite direction. Some drivers blame the bridge, but others know that the bad traffic was there already.
PennDOT thought about this too: “The traffic modeling also indicated that traffic from Highland Park Bridge would not be significantly delayed.”
“It’s not a longer commute,” Mary from the Senior Citizen Center added, “it just seems that way. But the light is timed correctly. Traffic moves.”
Traffic patterns change as people move in and out of the city. Traffic patterns change as people buy different kinds of vehicles. Traffic patterns aren’t meant to be set in stone.
Things change. And even though I appreciate that the Pittsburgh Left has its own Wikipedia article, saving lives matters more than an old habit. Even if it means a stop light on a highway.
Adriana E. Ramírez, author of “Dead Boys,” is a columnist and InReview editor for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette: aramirez@post-gazette.com.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.