At one point in Abraham Verghese’s best-selling novel, “The Covenant of Water,” a character exclaims “Fiction is the great lie that tells the truth about how the world lives!”

He could have been speaking to his character’s aspirations as well as to his own — to capture through storytelling what historians and statistics cannot convey, how it actually feels to be alive in the world. But in following one Indian family for about eighty years, as well as the parallel story of a foreign doctor at a nearby leprosy clinic, Mr. Verghese seems deeply invested in the story of national identity as much as he does in his individual characters.

The family curse

The novel begins when a 12-year-old girl (Big Ammachi) arrives on a modest estate in southwestern India in 1900 to marry a widower thirty years her senior. It ends seventy-seven years later when her granddaughter makes a startling discovery related to the family curse.

Advertise with us

Because the family is cursed: In every generation, someone drowns. The “Condition,” as they call it, affects everyone, not just the dead. Mothers grieve their children, siblings grow up paranoid of water, the swimmers in the family must keep their passions hidden. Water is to be avoided. But in the southwestern region of India, now known as Kerala, with its many canals, rivers and streams, they can’t avoid the water.

The family lives off the land. Parambil, their estate, is a constant presence in a novel with a large character count. Big Ammachi’s house is a place of love and birth, dirt and water, as well as tragedy and sorrow. Mr. Verghese loves its landscape, dedicating paragraph after paragraph to luscious descriptions of the panorama that are as engrossing as the plot.

“The Covenant of Water” is an epic book — and not just because it clocks in at almost 800 pages. Like “One Hundred Years of Solitude” by Gabriel García Márquez, Mr. Verghese’s novel cares how individuals navigate the larger questions of alienation and survival, while creating an Indian identity in the periods before and after decolonization.

Most of the national story happens in the background: Indian soldiers going to war on behalf of Britain, the rumbles and struggles of independence, the influx of technology and development in a place that seemed untouched by modernity, the rise of a communist revolution, and the formation of the Indian republic. But other hallmarks of mid-century existence affect the characters directly: the last vestiges of British colonialism, the treatment of people in the lower castes, and evolving thoughts on opportunities for women.

Big Novels about Nation

Advertise with us

Big Novels about Nation are rare. “Midnight’s Children” by Salman Rushdie came out in 1981, a “A House for Mr. Biswas” by V. S. Naipaul in 1961, and “One Hundreds Years of Solitude” was published in 1967. The American equivalents, books like “The Grapes of Wrath” (1939) by John Steinbeck and “The Sound and the Fury” (1929) by William Faulkner, are from a much earlier era in fiction.

In this way, “The Covenant of Water” feels like a relic of the past. The concerns of contemporary fiction have shifted away from allegorical novels of nation and identity to novels about individuals facing conflict in a postmodern world.

It’s hard to find novels today that span eighty years, cycling through various generations of one family. We care a lot more about the individual protagonist, the mystery to be solved, the criminal getting caught, and the person navigating a system designed to keep them down.

And while some of those tropes are present here, the sheer scope of the story transcends any individual concerns. That doesn’t lessen the novel’s impact; I certainly found myself crying at certain points and angry at others. But the nature of the epic novel is that by the end of the book, characters from the beginning feel distant.

Mr. Verghese is an extraordinary writer, careful and deliberate in his prose. He’s also a doctor by training and a professor of the theory and practice of medicine and vice chair of education at Stanford University Medical School. So it’s no surprise that various characters in “The Covenant of Water” are doctors. Mr. Verghese’s writing shines during his descriptions of medicine.

Advertise with us

Even doctors can’t solve it

But even the doctors cannot solve it all. People still drown. Women still disappear. And India is still in flux, a nation forever defining itself even as it resists definition.

“The Covenant of Water” is a pleasure to read — an epic lie invested in the truth of who we are, and who a people can become.

Adriana E. Ramírez, author of “Dead Boys,” is a columnist and InReview editor for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette: aramirez@post-gazette.com. Her previous column was “A Republican in moderate’s clothing is still a Republican.”

Abraham Verghese will be giving a reading at Carnegie Library Lecture Hall on Monday, November 13th at 7:30 p.m. More information is available via Pittsburgh Arts & Lectures.