When news reached me that Hamas attacked Israel last week, I immediately texted two people I knew would disagree on the matter, “So Israel is at war?” One of them replied with “so it seems,” and began analyzing the strategies involved. The other simply replied with prayer emoji hands and a phrase that has been pin-balling in my brain since I received it, “I’m not quite sure what to think; let’s see how it plays out.”
Within minutes, my social media feeds were filled with statements. Statements from politicians and political analysts working at the national level made sense: They offered perspectives on what was happening, a clear framing of where our country’s media and decision-makers stand in relation to the conflict.
But there were other statements. Statements from celebrities. Statements from local politicians and candidates. A statement from my local coffee shop, and the store where I once bought a mattress. There were statements from adult entertainers on social media and from a singer I once saw perform at a cabaret. There was a statement from the woman who sells homemade kombucha in my neighborhood.
When did we all become publicists? Why do we need to comment on everything? Why does the mayor of Pittsburgh — a city as far removed from Gaza as one can imagine — have to comment on what’s happening in the Middle East?
Why do I need to know how everyone feels about everything all the time? Why are we all required to have an immediate take? What is the purpose of a statement of support?
I spoke to a professor of media studies about this phenomenon. They say that to some degree, we’ve always made statements, it’s just that we used to be more subtle about it.
Read More
Think of the yellow ribbons after 9/11. People wanted to express their patriotism and champion our armed forces, who were immediately dispatched to war. Because it was before social media, we had to get creative about it.
So we purchased yellow magnets and placed them on cars. In Texas, where I lived at the time, the grocery store parking lot was a sea of yellow ribbons. We were Americans, and we were united, and this was how we showed it.
Of course, not everyone was. I was in college at the time, and I knew people who dedicated themselves to stealing those magnetic ribbons. They weren’t promoting the enemy; they were simply sick of thoughtless and performative patriotism.
I remember one of my more punk-minded friends pointing out that “buying a yellow ribbon is easier than dealing with the American policies that got us here.” Her heavy-handed opinion was out of place, but because she never wrote it on social media, only her friends could hold her to account.
And part of me understood that I didn’t need to put a yellow ribbon on a car in order to be patriotic. I didn’t know how to articulate my disagreement with the ribbons, but I knew that someone with a ribbon on their car wasn’t more patriotic than anyone else. They were just better at signaling it.
Signaling what? To whom? And why?
In 2015, the UK’s “Spectator” magazine coined the term “virtue signaling” in an article about criticizing people who say or write things to make clear they are “admirably non-racist, leftwing or open-minded” — without actually doing anything to change the world.
Then in 2020, the BBC banned their employees from posting about politics on their social media accounts, employing a “no virtue signaling” policy. BBC guidelines define it more narrowly as “retweets, likes or joining online campaigns to indicate a personal view,” from all sides of the political spectrum.
“We expect these individuals to avoid taking sides on party political issues or political controversies and to take care when addressing public policy matters,” the BBC policy stated.
But most of us don’t “take care” when we post our opinions online.
And so, when an organization we are aligned with shares an unpopular view, are we required to disown them? If my coffee shop comes out with a pro-Palestinian statement that doesn’t explicitly condemn attacks by Hamas, can I still get my flat white there in the morning?
Must a candidate for local office disavow any and all statements her former allies make on an issue across the world? I guess so. Why were they commenting on international issues in the first place? Who knows.
Not everyone needs to issue a statement of solidarity. Not every social media account has to articulate feelings about everything in the zeitgeist. I don’t know how my next door neighbors feel about this war, and I’m not sure how they feel about Taylor Swift and Travis Kelce, and I’m not sure how they feel about Kevin McCarthy. I could go look up their social media profiles, but I prefer the mystery.
And that’s okay. I don’t need to know my neighbors’ every opinion to appreciate them as my neighbors. We shouldn’t know so much about each other. I think that’s part of the reason we’re so divided; everyone wants to be an opinion writer, but we’re simply creating more and more shibboleths that define and divide us.
I called my friend after a few days, the one who initially said “I’m not quite sure what to think; let’s see how it plays out.” She was saddened by the whole situation.
“It’s complicated,” she said of her feelings. “I could explain for two hours how all of this was messed up completely, and how it’s really all the British’s fault,” referring to the British occupation of Palestine before 1948.
“No one wants complexity, though,” she mourned. “Everyone wants a hot take, and my ‘hot take’ is to not have one. To hold space for grief, and for all the life that’s been lost.”
“But that won’t play well on social media.”
Adriana E. Ramírez, author of “Dead Boys,” is a columnist and InReview editor for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette: aramirez@post-gazette.com.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.