North Carolina politician Bo Hines declared on the radio last year that thanks to President Joe Biden, “we’re in a banana republic,” using a term politicians and pundits throw around as shorthand for “an economically and politically unstable nation.”

For example, in the days after the Jan. 6 Capitol riots, former President George W. Bush described rioting as “how elections are disputed in a banana republic.”

Former president Donald Trump said the many subsequent indictments against him are a sign that the U.S. is now a “banana republic.” Conservative David Frum offered a clarification, “it’s a banana republic when the president of the state commits crimes and DOESN’T face justice.”

Laura Ingraham, of Fox News, in light of all the indictments, sadly announced that to her the U.S. now “feels like a banana republic.”

Advertise with us

Real banana republics

It’s also the name of an upscale retail clothing chain store, and this seems to have confused Mr. Hines. “I think that’s an insult to Banana Republics across the country,” he continued. “I mean, at least the manager of Banana Republic — unlike our president — knows where he is and why he’s there and what he’s doing.”

A banana republic is not just a fashionable place to buy some overpriced linen pants. And it’s not an economically and politically unstable nation — it’s an economically and politically destabilized nation.

The term originated with short story master O. Henry back in 1904, when he was on the run from embezzlement charges in the U.S. He decided to take refuge in Honduras, a country that like many in the Caribbean at the time, was under the thumb of a multinational fruit company.

In “Cabbages and Kings,” a collection loosely based on his experiences in Honduras, he calls the fictional Republic of Anchuria a banana republic, as it was. Like the very real Honduras, it depended on the banana exporters that managed large plantations, often destabilizing local governments for their own needs.

Advertise with us

The American Cuyamel Fruit Company supported and instigated the 1911 coup in Honduras to replace a president antagonistic to American interests with one much more pliable. U.S. intervention in Latin America, first codified under the Monroe Doctrine, and later confirmed in 1904 by the Roosevelt Corollary, asserted the right of the U.S. to “help stabilize” the Americas by military intervention.

The U.S. did so in Cuba, Nicaragua, Haiti and the Dominican Republic — to name a few. It also “encouraged” Panama to secede from Colombia with military support and planning, in exchange for the Panamanians giving up their most important asset, the canal, for almost 100 years.

Finance over stability

Financial stakes mattered over actual stability in 20th-century American foreign policy. These companies exploited and exported tropical countries’ national resources. Local workers were left living in poverty on company land and eating from the company store. They were not paid enough to buy anything elsewhere, and the companies only benefited from keeping workers, and countries, financially dependent.

To quote poet Pablo Neruda, “The Fruit Company, Inc. reserved for itself the most succulent, the central coast of my own land, the delicate waist of the Americas. … It established a comic opera: it abolished free will, gave out imperial crowns, encouraged envy, attracted the dictatorship of flies.”

Advertise with us

Every time a pundit calls Colombia a “banana republic,” people remember the massacre of thousands of people at the hand of the United Fruit Company, described in Gabriel García Márquez’s novel “One Hundred Years of Solitude.” And Colombia wasn’t alone. The banana companies operated without oversight or remorse, and the environmental and human impacts of their depredations remain.

United Fruit continues operating under a different name and a different owner, but as Chiquita, it still imports many of the fruits we consume. Forget blood diamonds, we eat blood bananas.

American corporations continue to reap profits from these “banana republics.” If Guatemala and Honduras had been allowed to develop their own resources, without Americans taking all the financial benefits, would the U.S. still be seeing immigration from these countries?

If any country in the world is an expert on making banana republics, it’s us.

And what this really means, to people like me, is that the U.S. should really stop using that phrase to describe any other country. Because if a country happens to be a “banana republic,” it’s most likely our fault.

Advertise with us

Still, most of the banana republics remain, despite it all. And sadly, I’m not sure the U.S. is capable of enduring the routine instability these countries endure. One indicted ex-president and we’re floundering.

We’re worse

So, no, a banana republic we are not. We’re something much worse than that — a country that thought itself above corruption, even as we exploited our continental neighbors to their detriment. We deserve our current “comic opera,” but we haven’t earned the martyred history that comes with the phrase.

We don’t deserve to be called a “banana republic.” I’m not even sure we deserve a pair of nice pants.

Adriana E. Ramírez, author of “Dead Boys,” is a columnist and InReview editor for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette: aramirez@post-gazette.com. Her previous column was “How Mexico came to bleed black and gold.”