Pittsburgh blogger and author Mark Craven was scrolling through social media when he found a friend’s post. It was something about masculinity, he recalls. “I don’t even know exactly what his post was, but I wrote, ‘Dads, kiss your sons’ and it hit me — oh, that’s the message, that’s why I went through all this crazy stuff, to become the dad that I am today.”
Father’s Day is not easy for everyone. For most people, it’s a celebration of dad — a reason to buy khaki pants, ties and whiskey glasses to honor their old man. But so many people around us are unfathered due to estrangement, death, absence and complicated family dynamics. Father’s Day can be a painful reminder of something they never quite had or understood.
Mr. Craven is no stranger to this. His story, which he chronicles in his self-published and inspirational memoir “Dads, Kiss Your Sons” (available on Amazon), is a testament to the importance of fatherhood. As a child, he was raised by a single mother, and as he pointed out in an interview, “I didn’t have a dad, and I didn’t have a great relationship with my mom.” And so as an adult, he sought out a relationship with the man he’d been told was his father.

For a few years they connected. But then a DNA test revealed this father wasn’t biologically connected to him. Suddenly Mr. Craven went from having a good relationship with a once-ostracized Italian-American father, to having no father at all. After he grilled his mother about it, she revealed that his real father was a journeyman wrestler who had once appeared on WWE (then called WWF). His biological father was also an African-American man. Suddenly, as Mr. Craven put it, “My ethnicity and sense of self changed overnight.”
In his memoir, he grapples with his mother’s racism, his own shifting views on identity and the difficulty of reconciling intergenerational views of fatherhood — backed up by a whole lot of research. As he said, “I found out that in the ’80s, about 80% of men said they never changed a diaper; for millennial fathers, it’s 5%.”
“And the interesting thing, with the millennial generation of fathers, is that we’ve incorporated being a father and being a dad into our identity. For so long our identity was really in our careers and in our work and what we did. But now the identity of dad is there too.”
Read More
Mr. Craven thinks that changing attitudes about parenting are necessary. “Too many fathers were not held accountable in the past. Too many fathers chose not to be around. I was raised by three women, and all of them taught me that there’s so much more to being a man than just making money and fathering [in the biological sense] children.” Mr. Craven credits these women with teaching him to be the best dad he can be, despite his lack of role models.
Feminism has played a part. There are more mothers in the workplace and because of this, more fathers are taking on the task of primary caregiving. During my kids’ preschool pickups, I see as many dads as I do moms, something I never witnessed in my own childhood.
My husband is a committed father: He does the errand-parts of parenting better than I do, and while he’s terrible at tracking the calendar, he’s so much more invested in our kids than society taught me to expect.

The generational shift has been good. Research shows that involved fathers improve many outcomes for their children, from learning more in school to escaping the prison pipeline. An engaged parent is better than an absent one, a statement so obvious that it makes one wonder why it took millennia for everyone to notice.
Families do not look the same as before. Fathers are not always cis-men; they are not always breadwinners; and they are not always too distracted by work and responsibilities to parent. Many households still function under the old model, but research seems to indicate that even those stereotypical dads, the ones who can’t change a diaper, are more involved than their own fathers ever were.
Mr. Craven hopes that every generation will have fewer stories like his. To be unfathered, Mr. Craven argues, is to be unanchored in this world. “I see Kai, my son, and I obviously see myself in him and I just couldn’t imagine being without him. It shatters my heart to think about that little boy just not being loved on like crazy.”
What Mr. Craven doesn’t say is that he was that boy — but not everyone who grows up with that void chooses, or is able, to turn their lemons into lemonade. So many of us live with father-shaped resentments in our hearts, and it’s refreshing to see someone turn that hurt into something good.
Mr. Craven is not in touch with either of his fathers: The man Mr. Craven considered his father refused his calls after the DNA test, and his biological father will not acknowledge his existence. But he did find family in a biological uncle and cousin who have fully embraced him.
“Fathers can be overrated,” he said laughing, even as he followed up with a comment on how serious he was about redefining fatherhood. He wanted to write a guide for men who suddenly became dads, like him, and who also never had a role model. As he writes in his book, “What if the whole idea of being a dad is so completely foreign to you that quantum mechanics seems easier to master?”
The answer for Mr. Craven is love. His memoir is a map to finding that love, even though there’s little in practical instruction.
“This book isn’t about changing diapers,” he said. “I’m teaching people how to be a dad, but some parts go without saying. I shouldn’t have to write about diapers. That’s just part of the job, bro!”
Adriana E. Ramírez is a columnist and InReview editor for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette: aramirez@post-gazette.com.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.