Political parties evolve as the world changes. The Republican party of 2023 should not be the Republican party of 1854. But the Republican party of 2023 isn’t even the Republican party of 2014.
Republicans used to believe in small government. I grew up in a Republican household in the 1980s, and the Republicans I knew believed in individual agency and opposed government intervention. Each person was responsible for their well-being and each community could be trusted to rule itself, because local governments knew the people better than the state or federal government ever could. The laws of Pittsburgh were written by and for the people of Pittsburgh.
Today, the party that preached small government oversaw an unprecedented growth in government. The party responsible for declaring that corporations are allowed free speech vindictively attacks corporations for doing exactly that. The party of letting states decide for themselves is now the party of national bans. The party of decentralization is the party whose state governments restrict the power of cities to govern themselves.
Republican politicians have passed exactly the kind of policies that they formerly claimed to abhor. So what does it mean to be a Republican today? From the rhetoric of current candidates for the presidency, it would seem that being Republican means hating and fearing trans people and immigrants, a far cry from the noble ideals of small government.
It’s about wedge issues. Consider former governor Nikki Haley’s assertion that the rise in trans rights is the biggest women’s issue of our time. Republican politicians, hoping to distract from the real issues like abortion rights and a rebounding economy, need the distraction and divisiveness of trans rights to rally their base.
But when Data for Progress asked voters about the legislation working through statehouses “aimed at limiting the rights of transgender and gay people in America,” 55% of self-identified Republicans thought it was excessive and that their party was “playing political theater and using these bills as a wedge issue.”
Read More
Immigration is another wedge issue driving the national debate. But harsh anti-immigrant legislation in Florida has begun to backfire to the detriment of small farmers and small business owners. Republicans are hurting their own base.
As migrant workers leave the state in droves and Floridians see what this will do to the agriculture, construction, and tourism industries, state Republican legislators are publicly saying that the bill was only passed “to scare people.” As Florida State Representative Rick Roth said, after explaining that the legislation lacked funding for enforcement, “I'm trying to tell people that it's more of a political bill than policy."
But what is all this political theater building toward? The easiest explanation is power, simply for the sake of having power. But maintaining power like this comes at an ideological cost — after all, how can a politician like Texas Governor Greg Abbott ever say he favors self-governance when he just eliminated it for the people of Houston and Austin? How can presidential candidate and Florida governor Ron DeSantis say he supports small businesses and farmers in Florida as their construction sites remain empty and their crops unpicked?
One of the things that I love about my country is how a few years into a national government under the Articles of Confederation, leaders convened to write the Constitution. They acknowledged that they had made mistakes and built something better. That spirit should guide the Republican party now.
Most Republican voters still think of themselves as belonging to the party of small government, small taxes, and support for small businesses. According to polling from Pew, most Republicans do not wish to limit the rights of LGBTQ+ people, and most Americans overall want sensible immigration reform that allows migrants to work fairly and legally.
But as the election season approaches, it’s clear that GOP politicians are betting on fear and hatred. And the worst part is that it will work — gerrymandering and low voter turnouts have succeeded where mass appeal failed.
I hope that the polling is right, and Republican leaders stop exploiting these over-inflated “wedge issues.” Both parties can debate policy centered on improving the lives of all Americans instead of picking on convenient scapegoats. Maybe politicians can start to see nuance: Republicans can admit that the economy did not collapse under President Biden, just like Democrats can admit that the social safety net they propose has an impossibly big price tag? A girl can dream.
Our grim reality is that Republican politicians are more invested in holding on to power than they are in representing the will of their own constituents. It’s time for the Republican party to stand for something more than fear and hatred — and be less afraid of what its own people believe.
Adriana E. Ramírez is a columnist and InReview editor for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette: aramirez@post-gazette.com. Her previous article was “Finding humanity in the helpers.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.