When we talk about immigrants in this country, we often reference people who do it “the right way.” Legal immigration is seen as good, necessary. But the average person, when pressed for the details, knows very little about legal versus illegal crossings.
Most Americans cannot correctly answer the following: Is requesting asylum legal? Does marrying an American citizen prevent deportation? Does entering legally prevent deportation? Do most undocumented immigrants enter through the southern border?
Yes — and a basic human right. No, marrying an American does not prevent deportation depending on a person’s status. No, a person can do everything perfectly and still be deported or denied entry. No, most undocumented people overstay tourist visas.

I know this because I am an immigrant. I arrived in the United States when I was three months old, and fate and circumstance have taught me a lot of immigration law. I worry about how little the average person knows, as there are consequences to that ignorance.
Often when I use the term “immigrant” to describe myself, people make wild assumptions about my background and how I arrived in the United States. I don’t really correct people because it isn’t any of their business how my family arrived in this country.
Except — I’m not being completely honest. When people assume I am or have been undocumented, I’m quick to reference my naturalization papers and the perfectly filled-out forms that accompanied me on every step of my years-long journey to citizenship.
Read More
In other words, I’ve been silently adding a “good” before “immigrant” every time I self-identify. It’s not something I’m proud of — it’s something the rhetoric of my adopted homeland has forced me to perform. Goodness for the sake of goodness’ sake.
But sometimes, even when a person is a model immigrant, even when a person is the epitome of “good,” and even when someone has done exactly as he or she should do, the game is still rigged against him.
A model immigrant
According to the Philadelphia Inquirer, in order to save his own life from ethnic violence, Christian M’Bagoyi left West Africa when he was 20 and arrived in the United States on a tourist visa. After his visa expired, he requested asylum and was denied.
As his Order for Deportation worked its way through the incredibly backlogged immigration court system, Mr. M’Bagoyi received an Order of Supervision, which essentially allowed him to legally live, work and pay taxes until his immigration status was resolved definitively.
Twenty years have passed. During that time, Mr. M’Bagoyi became a beloved member of his neighborhood and community. He married an American citizen, had two American children, and integrated himself into Philadelphia — a model and active citizen. He was the kind of person who volunteered at every daycare function — a better person than I will ever be.
Because of his Order of Supervision, Mr. M’Bagoyi’s marriage did not grant him eligibility for an Adjustment of Status Request, which would rescind the deportation order. He fought his order of deportation as best he could, appealing over the years, and hoping to postpone his deportation as long as possible.
And then, without warning and in front of his children and community, ICE came for Christian M’Bagoyi. Just like that, a father, husband, and provider disappeared from his family, removed to a country where his life is in peril.

Never safe
Mr. M’Bagoyi was a good citizen, even if he wasn’t an official citizen. He did not break any laws and he dutifully renewed any and all paperwork required by Immigrations and Customs Enforcement. In fact, in an irony worthy of Kafka, his family suspects that renewing his work permit is what triggered the deportation in the first place.
The only possible mark against Mr. M’Bagoyi is that he requested asylum after arriving with a tourist visa. But asylum requests can take decades, whereas tourist visas are granted quickly. Someone needing to get out of danger cannot be blamed for taking a quick exit. How many of us would do the same thing if staying home suddenly became life-threatening?
ICE’s actions seem capricious and cruel because they are. Because our entire immigration system is backlogged and a twenty-year delay is not enough to automatically make someone eligible for permanent residence. People settle here, get married and integrate into a country that is effectively dangling a sword over their heads — but at least Damocles got to be king.
Where’s the good?
Ripped from his wife and children, Mr. M’Bagoyi now has to call them from a nation whose name we cannot print for his own safety. His family has been left without most of their income. One government agency’s caprice will now increase the burden on other families and agencies, for no reason other than that someone at ICE decided Mr. M’Bagoyi’s time was up.
Who benefits from this? What good is being done in removing Christian M’Bagoyi? I cannot find it, no matter where I look. The man paid his dues. The moral and ethical action is to return this man to his family — but our labyrinthine immigration laws make that almost impossible.

Politicians of all kinds will say that we need “good immigrants.” Who are these good immigrants, if not Christian M’Bagoyi?
Most of what we know about immigrants is wrong. Immigrants commit fewer crimes than non-immigrants. Only a microscopic percentage of immigrants have anything to do with cartels or the fentanyl crisis. Most of them are people in need and willing to work.
Undocumented labor keeps our produce prices low and our construction costs reasonable: We’re happy to benefit from the work of legal and illegal immigrants, while continuing to demonize them in the same breath. We speak of our crisis in nursing and health services, while ignoring the fact that immigrants make up a significant portion of people in those professions.
Yes, we need to keep out the bad folks. Yes, we need to fight fentanyl and other drugs crossing the borders. Yes, we need to go after the cartels. But the good people, the ones who are coming to the country to make it better — the vast majority of immigrants — need to be acknowledged too.
Christian M’Bagoyi deserved a chance to live the American dream. He did nothing wrong. But in a country without nuance, it doesn’t matter who is good — and most people won’t notice, know or care. We can change that. We can get it right. We should start by bringing Christian M’Bagoyi home.
Adriana E. Ramírez is a columnist and InReview editor for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette: aramirez@post-gazette.com.







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.