Scott W. Stern, a Pittsburgh native, is author of “The Trials of Nina McCall: Sex, Surveillance, and the Decades-Long Government Plan to Imprison ‘Promiscuous’ Women,” published in May by Beacon Press.

•

University of Pittsburgh trustees last month voted to remove from a university building the name of Thomas Parran, who served as U.S. surgeon general from 1936 to 1948 and was founding dean of Pitt’s Graduate School of Public Health.

For decades, Parran has been notorious for overseeing the infamous Tuskegee syphilis experiments, in which the government withheld treatment from poor black men with syphilis in rural Alabama from 1932 to 1972. In more recent years, Parran gained additional notoriety for his role in overseeing an even crueler study the government conducted in Guatemala, in which government officials intentionally infected female sex workers with syphilis.

Advertise with us

So, the renaming was long overdue. However, there is another way Thomas Parran’s legacy remains with the residents of Pittsburgh — one that virtually no one knows about. A law, which never would have passed without Parran’s personal influence and life’s work, remains on the books in Pennsylvania. Though no longer invoked, it remains a potential tool of oppression, one that should be viewed with deep suspicion. To understand it, we first need to unearth a century’s worth of largely forgotten history.

As I discovered while examining Parran’s papers in Pitt’s archive, Parran was instrumental in overseeing another oppressive government program: the American Plan. Under the American Plan, government officials imprisoned tens of thousands — probably hundreds of thousands — of women, suspected of having syphilis or gonorrhea, for months at a time without due process. Under this program, which lasted in Pennsylvania from the 1910s into the 1950s, and in many other places across the country into the 1960s and 1970s, imprisoned women were often “treated” for sexually transmitted infections (STIs) with injections of mercury or arsenic-based drugs. Some of these women were beaten and abused, or sterilized. One called the institution in which she was incarcerated a “concentration camp.”

Here in Pittsburgh, it appears that thousands of women were imprisoned over the years for nothing more than having an infection. According to one report, either 183 or 187 women were imprisoned for having STIs in Pittsburgh in 1932 alone — in a detention wing of the Mayview Hospital, which older residents may still remember.

Back in 1919, as a young Public Health Service physician, Thomas Parran had personally urged local officials in rural Alabama to enforce the American Plan, which they did. Decades later, as surgeon general, Parran oversaw and expanded the American Plan, even as he supervised the experiments in Tuskegee and Guatemala.

When, in 1948, President Harry Truman chose not to reappoint Parran as surgeon general, Parran moved to Pittsburgh to become founding dean of Pitt’s Graduate School of Public Health. It was largely because of this role that Pitt’s board of trustees chose, in 1969, to name a building after Parran.

Advertise with us

As late as the early 1950s, Pennsylvania still imprisoned women under the American Plan. But in 1952, after the effectiveness of penicillin became clearer to state health officials, Pennsylvania adopted a system of “appointment clinics” — suspected individuals would usually not be arrested but rather would be given appointments for STI exams at a local clinic.

In early 1956, however, the state enacted a new “Disease Prevention & Control Law.” This law enabled local health officers to compel suspected individuals to undergo examinations for various communicable diseases, including STIs. “If such a person refuses the examination, the medical officer can quarantine him until it is determined he is not infected,” summarized the Post-Gazette. “If the person still refuses to undergo examination, the court may commit him to an institution suitable for the care of cases of the disease he is suspected of having.” The new law repealed the state’s previous American Plan law “but provided adequate legal coverage for all aspects of venereal disease control,” reported state health officials.

Just why Pennsylvania legislators chose to do this in 1956 — a decade after penicillin had rendered syphilis and gonorrhea easily treatable — can seem confounding, until one reads a few paragraphs further down in the Post-Gazette article. “Sponsored by the State Health Department and backed by the administration the ‘disease prevention and control law’ is the result of studies made by the University of Pittsburgh Public Health Law project.”

This makes perfect sense, when one considers who was still the dean of the School of Public Health at Pitt in 1956: Thomas Parran. Parran, who had recruited most of the school’s first generation of faculty, “made Pittsburgh a proving ground for ideas developed during his tenure at PHS,” in the words of historian Lynne Page Snyder. Though exact details of his influence on Pitt’s studies and their connection to the new law are sketchy, it is hardly a stretch to imagine that Parran, as well as many state health officials, believed maintaining the state’s ability to examine and even quarantine those suspected of carrying STIs to be paramount. This law never would have passed without the American Plan — which, for decades, Parran had made possible.

Though there is no sensible public health rationale for being able to compulsorily examine or quarantine anyone merely suspected of having an STI — none at all — this law remains on the books to this day. It, too, is part of Parran’s disturbing legacy.