The executive order signed by President Donald Trump that would allow businesses to defer withholding certain payroll taxes makes little sense for either employers or their employees.
When the president and congressional leaders could not come to an agreement to extend certain benefits during the coronavirus pandemic, Mr. Trump authorized the option of a temporary halt on collecting the employee share of Social Security taxes — 6.2% of earnings. That would mean a bump in paychecks through the end of the year for most employees earning less than $104,000 a year.
For someone earning approximately $64,000 a year — the median U.S. household income in 2018, according to the Census Bureau — the tax deferral would amount to a pay increase of nearly $1,200 through the end of the year.
That’s the good news. The bad news is that the taxes are only deferred, not forgiven.
So the bigger paycheck through the end of the year would also mean a much smaller paycheck come January when employers would be required to start collecting not only the usual 6.2% tax, but also the amount that was deferred.
That hardly seems like an option employees would welcome, and it presents myriad headaches for employers who would be responsible for tracking the deferred taxes, making sure they are deducted from paychecks next year and paid to the federal government.
In fact, it’s hard to see much benefit at all for employers to exercise this option.
The bigger paychecks would go to people who are already working; the nearly 27 million unemployed Americans would gain no benefit from the payroll tax deferral.
And while the theory is that having more money would mean an increase in consumer spending, the fact is that many Americans are choosing to save at the moment, rather than spend.
Commerce Department figures show that the savings rate soared to a record 33.5% in April at the outset of the pandemic. It has edged downward since, but still stood at 19% by the end of June. Before the pandemic, Americans were saving an average of 7.5% of income.
While consumer spending rose by 5.6% in June as the economy began reopening, it showed only a modest 1.9% increase in July.
The U.S. Chamber of Commerce and more than 30 trade associations, in a letter to Congress and the Treasury Department, said many of their members will likely decline to defer the payroll tax.
“Many of our members consider it unfair to employees to make a decision that would force a big tax bill on them next year,” the letter said.
A payroll tax deferral won’t put money into the hands of those who need it most and would likely spend it quickly. Congress and the Trump administration should go back to negotiating on proposals such as another round of stimulus checks and increased unemployment benefits.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.