Lucy Flores, a former Nevada assemblywoman and ex-Bernie Sanders staffer, recently claimed that former Vice President Joe Biden inappropriately touched her at a 2014 event. Around the same time, a viral photo from 2015 resurfaced, showing Mr. Biden in a similar touchy-feely moment with Stephanie Carter during her husband Ashton Carter’s 2014 swearing-in as secretary of defense.

In a piece published last Sunday at medium.com, Mrs. Carter noted her gratitude for Mr. Biden’s support on that important day but affirmed Ms. Flores’ “right to speak her truth,” stating, “She should be, like all women, believed.”

Because women don’t lie? “T.F.” of Zelienople knows otherwise. He was accused twice of sexual assault during his sophomore year at Seneca Valley Intermediate High School. The young women were believed and action taken, resulting in enormous destruction in his life.

In Joe Biden’s case, there is photographic evidence of his long-established physicality. The only thing to “believe” or not is what each woman feels about this and whether his habits disqualify him from public service.

Advertise with us

But believing how women say they feel about undisputed actions is monumentally different from believing women about whether an action ever took place. We must never lose sight of that difference — political correctness be damned.

T.F.’s nightmare began in July 2017, at a summer job as a lifeguard at the Zelienople Community Pool, where a girl accused him of sexual assault. He lost his job, was criminally charged and placed on juvenile probation, got taunted at school as a “predator,” was shackled and removed from class upon the second accusation, and spent nine days in a juvenile facility — released only after further investigation turned up evidence of conspiracy against him.

T.F., a junior, is now in cyber school. His months of pain led to a federal lawsuit filed in October 2018 by his parents, Michael Flood Jr. and Alecia Flood, against all the girls, their parents, the school district, Butler County and the Butler County district attorney’s office.

Awaiting a hearing in the case Friday, the Floods’ attorney Craig Fishman was philosophical about certain aspects of the nation’s zeitgeist. “In the era of Bill Cosby and Harvey Weinstein and Matt Lauer,” he said, “no one wants to be perceived as anti-woman.” Officials must try to prevent a predator roaming free, he said, “but you probably need to evaluate the evidence before you incarcerate someone or suspend him from school.”

In T.F.’s case, the second accusation soon unraveled and revealed that the first charge was also false, involving some of the same young women, most of whom have confessed.

Advertise with us

The percentage of false assault allegations is hotly contested. Women activists claim it’s only 2 percent, but criminologist Brent Turvey says that figure “has no basis in reality.”

Head of the Forensic Criminology Institute, Mr. Turvey, in “False Allegations,” an analysis of statistical studies, FBI and police crime reports and military data, found estimates that range from 8 percent to 25 percent, depending on the organization.

Mr. Turvey’s research was discovered by conservative news outlets and the Associated Press during the Brett Kavanaugh hearings but otherwise overlooked.

There is no doubt that countless women have suffered indignities, and worse, from men for millennia. I have, and women I know and trust have, too. But some women have lied, causing men to suffer. From T.F.’s case to 2013’s “Jane Doe” at Occidental University, to the “Mattress Girl” at Columbia University, women’s stories were believed when they could have been refuted.

The answer to humanity’s woes is not to believe women no matter what. The answer is to listen to women, take their experiences seriously and believe the evidence. It is not too strong to say that if we abandon this standard, we abandon civilization. What happened to “T.F.” was certainly not the just act of a civilized society.

Ruth Ann Dailey is a columnist for the Post-Gazette (ruthanndailey@hotmail.com).