Poets are the unacknowledged legislators of the world,” the English poet Percy Bysshe Shelley wrote to another poet in 1821. The quote was published years later in 1840 when Romanticism was at its height with both the English aristocracy and the bohemian intelligentsia.

In America, poets were pushed aside a long time ago by popular entertainers who generate culturewide discussions that transcend the narrow confines of whatever category they find themselves slotted in.

This is what happened last week when actor/​director/​musician Donald Glover, in his persona as Childish Gambino, released the video single “This Is America” shortly after his appearance as host and musical guest on “Saturday Night Live.”

Immediately, “This Is America” provoked fierce analysis about its meaning that was not limited to fans of Childish Gambino’s Afro-futuristic hip-hop. Passionate defenders and detractors wrote essays on social media that pointed out thematic links to everything from 19th-century Jim Crow imagery to Dylann Roof’s massacre at Emanuel African Methodist Episcopal Church, with Abu Ghraib and police violence thrown in.

Advertise with us

Still, no consensus emerged about “This Is America” except that it is shocking. The violence it contains is so unexpected, yet reminiscent of the kind of violence we take for granted as Americans.

Like the title of the song and video suggests, the violence is “American” to its core. This is America! American violence is so familiar that we don’t take much notice of it until a video comes along to remind us that there is something profoundly weird and tragic about it.

Mr. Glover has proven himself an adept maestro of surrealism and social commentary with two seasons of his TV show “Atlanta.” In this video,  he disarms the viewer at first. Shirtless and standing in the middle of what looks like an empty warehouse space, Mr. Glover dances slowly while a seated guitarist plays an arpeggio in counterpoint to the raised voices of an unseen choir.

Moving in sync to the music, the character Mr. Glover plays moves toward the guitar player, who now has his head covered with a bag. What happens next constitutes the first nightmare in a video with several shocks.

The shirtless man’s dancing is simultaneously sensuous, joyful and dangerous. Through it all, he scrunches his face, pops his eyes and grimaces like the depictions of the trickster negroes in political cartoons two centuries ago.

Advertise with us

Dancers join him until it becomes clear he’s too volatile to spend much time accompanying. They scatter when he stops dancing to point his fingers in an aggressive manner, even though no weapon is visible.

“This Is America” is a song and video about the contradictions of being an American. The black body is the nation’s eternal victim of circumstances — the black body that always “wins” the lottery that ends in a funeral pyre.

The violence that rains down on the black people in “This Is America” is shocking, but other than the immediate victims, the witnesses aren’t crushed by it. They continue dancing, moving forward, either trying to make sense of it or ignoring it. Those dancers represent the overwhelming majority of Americans of all colors and persuasions looking for entertainment, enlightenment and salvation from shirtless pop icons who are often mercurial, clueless or downright crazy.

Donald Glover has refused to explain the video’s meaning, preferring to let the images speak for itself. This is wise because literally nothing he could say would satisfy everyone. Viewers are literal even when confronted by something as surreal as American violence, especially when most have forgotten how racialized it is. People would simply reject what he has to say in favor of their own interpretation.

The “beauty” of the video is that it gets us talking and remembering what kind of country we’ve lived in since before it was a constitutional republic. The video is beautifully layered, with panic everywhere in the background, while a choreographed Dionysian narrative full of violence happens in the foreground.

Advertise with us

All theories are fascinating, but irrelevant. Mr. Glover will never condescend to explain his creation — nor should he. He’s an artist, not a critic or a psychologist. If you’re an American, you know what “This Is America” means.

Tony Norman: tnorman@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1631.