Sean Penn is a brilliant actor and, judging by his relief work in Haiti, a serious humanitarian. As a journalist, though, he’s an entertaining stenographer.

His Rolling Stone article about meeting up with drug lord Joaquin Guzman in Mexico is a tour de force of self-indulgence and obfuscation, painting the brutal gangster as a “simple man from a simple place.” The magazine’s website published the account Saturday night, a day after Mexican authorities captured the Sinaloa syndicate leader known as “El Chapo,” whose legend had been enhanced by two escapes from top-security Mexican prisons.

Law-abiding American citizens may ask: Did Mr. Penn break laws by consorting with a major criminal who is wanted on numerous charges in the United States? Didn’t he have an obligation to report the kingpin’s whereabouts to the FBI?

This is a less-than-ideal case, but journalists must defend First Amendment rights, resist pressure to reveal a source and refuse to collect intelligence on behalf of government agencies. Fortunately, in this case, Mexican authorities have said Mr. Penn unwittingly helped them locate Guzman; the journey to his lair, made with Mexican actress Kate del Castillo, may have created a visible trail.

Advertise with us

Journalists would have a harder time defending an interview with someone who poses an imminent lethal threat. In March 1997, two CNN reporters managed to score an exclusive with Osama bin Laden in Afghanistan. The same interview, conducted post-9/​11, would have resulted in outrage.

Despite Mexico’s pervasive corruption, Guzman was bound to be located by law enforcement, which had been humiliated by his July 2015 escape. Mr. Penn’s excursion, linked to Ms. Del Castillo’s intention of producing a biopic about the notorious drug purveyor, is best understood as Hollywood business at the extreme.

As actor Matt Damon told Entertainment Weekly, “It’s nothing new, actors going and seeking out meetings like this. ... Sean somehow figured out that he had an audience with this person and I’m sure was pursuing something creatively.” We look forward to Mr. Penn getting back to his day job.

Meet the Editorial Board.