In South Huntingdon, Westmoreland County, foes of a proposed power plant are in a difficult situation. They don’t have the law on their side. They don’t even have a law.
Thirty-seven percent of Pennsylvania municipalities lack zoning ordinances, according to the state, and South Huntingdon is one of them. That has complicated some residents’ efforts to fight, or at least shape, a Nebraska company’s construction of a 950-megawatt natural-gas power plant on 50 acres.
While Tenaska has considered building the plant at least since 2009, concern is mounting now because the permitting process is underway, the county approval process is completed and the company has set a groundbreaking for this summer.
Opponents fear the plant will be too close to their properties, disturb their rural lifestyle and bring pollution. County officials say they have provided residents with as much protection as they can — making sure the developer adheres to setback standards, for example — but county laws do not regulate land use.
Municipal zoning ordinances do that. Yet Shirl Barnhart, chairman of the Morgan supervisors in Greene County and of the Pennsylvania State Association of Township Supervisors executive board, said many municipalities lack zoning because residents don’t want the cost of developing the ordinances and don’t want government telling them what to do with their property.
In areas of little development or those dominated by forest or game lands, there may seem to be no need for zoning, said Elam M. Herr, the association’s assistant executive director. Only when a threat emerges do the benefits of zoning become clear.
About six years ago, a methadone clinic controversy in another municipality prompted Morgan and a handful of neighbors to develop a joint zoning plan and form a joint zoning board. While municipalities can’t entirely exclude a type of business, Mr. Barnhart said, they can relegate dangerous or problematic ones to low-impact areas and impose other safeguards. He said the ordinance has helped to guide Marcellus shale development, among other growth.
Zoning ordinances help communities grow in sensible ways. For that reason, more municipalities should adopt them.


Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.