It’s no surprise that UPMC and Highmark will begin the new year the way they ended the old one — at each other’s throats.
As Jan. 1 dawns, so will the long-threatened (by UPMC) and much-resisted (by Highmark) divorce of the region’s health care giants. Although there is no way to avoid this unhappy ending, it comes, like a lot of separations, with an added side show.
This one unfolded last week, when state officials from the insurance department, health department and attorney general’s office sent a letter to CEOs Jeffrey Romoff of UPMC and David Holmberg of Highmark ordering the nonprofits into binding arbitration under the terms of last summer’s consent decree.
The letter said only that the issue was “physician contracts” — apparently the failure of the parties to agree on the status of 700 UPMC physicians whose Highmark contracts were terminated by the insurer last month. Highmark said it did that to clarify for its customers which physicians would stay in-network after its contract with UPMC expires. Afterward UPMC announced that Highmark’s Medicare Advantage plans would be out-of-network for its doctors and facilities, meaning significantly higher costs for those Highmark customers. And they call this a caring profession.
The state officials’ letter said, “We are disappointed that after our numerous efforts to bring the parties together, you are still unable to reach an agreement in the interests of western Pennsylvania consumers, in particular given the general agreement of the parties on core underlying principles.”
Thank goodness the consent decree contains a provision to settle the issues that Highmark’s and UPMC’s executives can’t — or won’t. But it’s a shame that the nonprofits, despite the promises of their glossy commercials, need an arbitrator to show them how to handle their customers.
They sure know how to take the charity out of charitable organization.


Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.