Sometimes a visit to the doctor can come with a shock — like the shock of a troubling diagnosis or the shock (and relief) of an old affliction suddenly cured.
But nothing prepared Western Pennsylvanians for the shock over the weekend that came from UPMC. For months it has run TV commercials and newspaper ads warning that Highmark insurance customers could lose access to in-network treatment at UPMC on Jan. 1 if they don’t switch insurance plans. Now the company, according to an email Friday from its chief medical officer to its physicians, will launch an outreach campaign this week to tell the Highmark customers who stayed put that they — and their insurance dollars — are welcome at UPMC, so long as those customers are currently under UPMC care.
Why didn’t UPMC say this in the first place?
UPMC executives contend the company has been saying, since the state approved the Highmark-UPMC consent decrees in the summer, just what Steven Shapiro’s email told UPMC doctors last week — that “any Highmark patients under your care, whether it is for preventive, acute or chronic care, have the right to continue in your care at in-network rates.”
One provision in the decrees is a “safety net” clause that lets certain UPMC patients with Highmark coverage see UPMC doctors for another year, if they are “unable to find alternative physicians and services” nearby. Another is a “continuity of care” section that runs five years and says UPMC and Highmark agree that continuation of care of a Highmark customer who is in the middle of treatment at UPMC shall occur at in-network rates.
How to interpret the decrees led Highmark and UPMC to face off against each other before the state’s insurance commission, health secretary and attorney general, and sent Highmark to Commonwealth Court. Yet now UPMC would have consumers believe that they had nothing to worry about? Were they not supposed to be paying attention to the doomsday scenarios portrayed in UPMC ad campaigns? It’s no surprise that patients and policy holders, relying on the health-care giants for specifics, saw nothing in UPMC’s marketing that assured them of a chance to keep their UPMC doctors at in-network rates. But don’t take our word for it; here are UPMC’s words:
• “Get complete access to UPMC and have complete peace of mind.”
• “CHOOSE WISELY: If you automatically enroll in the same health plan you bought last year you could be missing out.”
• “All this [Highmark actions] could mean no affordable in-network access to any UPMC facility or service, no UPMC doctors, no ‘continuity of care,’ no ‘safety net’ and no limitation on out-of-network charges. No nothing. So be careful during your employer’s open enrollment to choose a plan that gives you and your family the access to UPMC that you want.”
The assurances that UPMC physicians will now be giving to Highmark customers on keeping in-network treatment are hard to read, even between the lines, of UPMC’s marketing.
In Pittsburgh’s competitive health care marketplace, UPMC likes to remind people of Highmark’s need to shift thousands of customers into hospital beds at Highmark’s Allegheny Health Network. At the same time, UPMC has tried to steer as many insurance customers as possible away from Highmark — until the enrollment periods closed. Now it’s eager to keep the dollars of many of the remaining Highmark customers as revenue for UPMC services.
We wonder how many Highmark customers might feel about all of this, especially if they’ll be paying more money next year for a plan they switched to, just to keep UPMC access.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.