Point Park University took a wise course when it made moving the Pittsburgh Playhouse from Oakland to Downtown a priority in its long-term planning. Now it has a chance to make an equally smart decision to retain and preserve a lovely piece of city history. Three pieces, actually, the terracotta facades of the former Honus Wagner sporting goods store and two adjacent buildings.

Together, the three structures, 320, 322 and 330 Forbes Avenue, have been staples of Downtown life since the turn of the 20th century. Situated on what once was known as Diamond Alley, one housed the 1889 Beaux Arts-style Palace Theater and the others variously were home to popular lunchtime restaurants and retail stores, until Honus Wagner shut its doors in 2011.

Point Park’s plan for the site includes the latest incarnation of the playhouse — a main-stage auditorium with 500 seats, two black-box theaters, studios and other vital features of a modern facility. Unfortunately, the buildings themselves are not fit for rehabilitation, but their handsome faces can still be saved.

When the university won approval for its project from the Pittsburgh Planning Commission a year ago, it promised to preserve the facades but said the scrolled brackets, swags, wreaths and other elements would be reconstructed in a courtyard that will be part of the playhouse complex. Point Park can do better than that.

Advertise with us

These beautiful features should be cleaned, restored and put back up on the front of the new building, facing Forbes. Downtown architect Rob Pfaffmann has produced some samples of how they could work in Point Park’s overall design, and the university’s architect should be given the challenge to do the same thing.

Moving the playhouse from its longtime home in Oakland will add to the Downtown arts scene. Repositioning the facades to Point Park’s complex will contribute to the historic character of the Forbes Avenue corridor. That twin bill deserves enthusiastic applause.