As multitudes of patients in Western Pennsylvania get used to the notion that UPMC and Highmark are going their separate ways beginning Jan. 1, it’s time for the two health care giants to get used to it, too.

Last week, Highmark insurance said it was terminating the commercial contracts of 700 UPMC doctors to provide “a level of clarity” to its members about which doctors will be in-network, and which won’t, after the big split. According to Highmark, the terminations will still leave 80 percent of UPMC physicians in-network for its insurance customers in 2015.

Highmark’s announcement was met with howls of protest from UPMC, whose spokesman said, “This is simply the next step by an increasingly desperate Highmark to exclude all UPMC physicians from all products they offer.”

Exclusion? What about UPMC’s exclusion of Highmark customers?

Advertise with us

UPMC launched the exclusion contretemps when it declared in 2013 that it would not renew its contract with the region’s largest health insurer, thereby excluding the bulk of Highmark customers from in-network UPMC services and facilities. UPMC says it made that choice because Highmark, with its acquisition of the Allegheny Health Network, had become a competitor in the hospital business.

Nevertheless, UPMC shouldn’t behave as though Highmark is the first — or only — one of the two to exclude people seeking health care. It’s clear that both are now fighting for competitive advantage under the terms of the consent decree hatched under state supervision and any clarifying rulings that either party can get from a state judge.

It’s ugly out there and getting uglier. Both UPMC and Highmark would do best to be clear about the choices that patients face in the brave new world of health care, instead of carping about who’s excluding whom.