President Barack Obama’s decision, codified in a secret order, to prolong U.S. troops’ combat role in the Afghanistan war by another year is difficult to understand from the perspective of America’s best interests.

What is the usefulness of the continued involvement of 22,000 American troops in what is, now and historically, one of the great political sinkholes of the world? Alexander the Great, the British, the Soviet Union and now the United States have sought to determine events in Afghanistan, each unsuccessfully. It is unclear what could make Mr. Obama or any of his advisers imagine that another 12 months of U.S. combat could make a difference there.

More than 2,200 American lives have already been lost and $4 trillion spent on the 13-year-long war. It might be that the election of Ashraf Ghani this year to replace Hamid Karzai as Afghan president will make a difference for the survival prospects of a non-Taliban government, but, really, how important is it to the United States who is president of Afghanistan?

The usual argument for a continued U.S. presence there is to prevent another 9/​11-style attack on Americans. The assurance that such an event would not originate in Afghanistan comes from the thorough satellite and drone coverage that the United States can maintain, with or without troops on the ground. Al-Qaida, which was working out of Afghanistan in 2001, has been overtaken by the Islamic State as the principal U.S. nemesis now anyway.

Advertise with us

Mr. Obama’s secret decision on Afghanistan, put alongside his decision earlier this month to double the U.S. troop level in Iraq, which Americans thought their military had left at the end of 2011 as promised, raises the question of what is going on in Washington, as well as in Mr. Obama’s reasoning. It is unclear what role, if any, his actions in Afghanistan and Iraq had to do with Secretary of Defense Chuck Hagel’s decision to resign.

Regardless, Mr. Obama’s decision to prolong America’s role in the conflict in Afghanistan was wrong and will not serve the interests of the United States.