Pope Francis has expressed his desire that the Catholic Church function like a “field hospital.” Perhaps the first real test of this is the extraordinary two-week gathering of the Synod of Bishops that continues through this week. This meeting is the first half of a discussion that will conclude in 2015 with an ordinary meeting of the Synod of Bishops on the same topic.

Will the results be caring actions that meet the needs of the people? The pope has taken several measures in an attempt to make it so.

First, he has identified something that needs treatment: marriage and family. In the United States, so many forces work against marriage while, at the same time, marriage has become essential for making it in our society.

Both parents have to work to cover food, shelter, gas and bills, yet this leaves little time for parents to be present for their children. The stability of families and investment of parents in their children has been shown time and again to be essential to children’s success in school, yet single parenthood is on the rise and support for these parents is on the decline. More and more young adults hope for happy marriages while becoming more aware of the epidemic of sexual assault.

Advertise with us

Pope Francis has also chosen a topic on which the Catholic Church provides some “medicinal” teaching. Catholicism’s understanding of marriage is not fundamentally condemnation but rather that families are domestic churches where people learn to love like Christ loves, that economic andpolitical spheres are to serve the family and that families are places where people learn to care for the vulnerable, such as the young, the old and the neighbor. These are remedies the church can offer to help what ails so many relationships.

Finally, Pope Francis wants the Catholic Church to have a good bedside manner, listening to patients. He asked bishops to survey members of their dioceses to understand their concerns about marriage and family, data that was eventually published in “The Pastoral Challenges of the Family in the Context of Evangelization.” He invited married couples to attend the Synod of Bishops. He set a precedent for approaching family issues pastorally instead of critically or disapprovingly.

Unfortunately, the discourse leading up to the meeting looked more like a political campaign. And now, despite the synod’s interim statement yesterday calling for the church to listen more and apply mercy more widely, the campaign continues.

Two sides have emerged. This is why Pope Francis remarked when he opened the gathering of bishops that “synod assemblies are not meant to discuss beautiful and clever ideas, or to see who is more intelligent.” Instead, he said, they should be nurturing, creative conversations.

Back in early 2014, Cardinal Walter Kasper of Germany spoke to the Consistory of Cardinals in a kind of overture for the meetings of the synod. His remarks were published in “The Gospel of the Family,” which explored the theological foundations of marriage and argued for allowing certain divorced and remarried Catholics to receive communion.

Advertise with us

In “Remaining in the Truth of Christ: Marriage and Communion in the Catholic Church,” five cardinals and four scholars stake out an opposing position, claiming that the Catholic Church’s position on marriage and communion cannot change.

Groups of people have grown around each of these contrary positions. The possibility of reasonable people disagreeing or having asubstantive debate is diminished by the growing acrimony of their comments in the media. It very much seemed as if each party was seeking support as they headed into the synod.

The result of a campaign approach is that reconciliation between opposing sides becomes nearly impossible. There is a winner and a loser. The complexities of the issues facing family life recede into the background, and where one stands on the single issue of communion for the divorced and remarried moves to the front.

This is not the hospital approach of “how do I help.” It is the confrontational approach of “how do I win.” While one of these parties might win by having their position affirmed at the synod, the losers would be all those families who need and long for the support and compassion of those who can help meet their many and varied needs.

Ultimately, the campaign approach is at odds with how Christians should behave as a church. As St. Paul wrote to the Christians at Ephesus, they should “do the truth in love” so that “the whole body, joined and held together by every supporting ligament, with the proper functioning of each part, brings about the body’s growth and builds itself up in love.”

Advertise with us

This approach would embody Francis’ field hospital, create a healthy body of believers and, perhaps most importantly, bring help to families.

Jason King is an associate professor and chair of the Theology Department at Saint Vincent College in Latrobe (jason.king@email.stvincent.edu).