A circus elephant had broken out of the Jaffa Mosque, Altoona’s live entertainment venue. That’s all I knew as I drove to the scene of the crime.
I was a reporter for the local paper working on deadline for the next day’s edition.
When I arrived at the mosque that cold, cloudy April day in 1993, I found the police forming an uneasy line in front of the venue’s lawn. There on the balcony, pacing, was the elephant. But that wasn’t what caught my eye at first. What caught my eye was the rifle in a policeman’s hands.
“You’re not gonna shoot it?” I said, trying to keep my voice neutral.
“If it charges the crowd, we’ll have to,” he replied. He was short and thick with muscle and age, his hair white, hands sure on that rifle. “That’s a public danger.”
I may have nodded in acknowledgement. Not long afterward, the circus owner ran up and convinced the police that shooting the elephant could be dangerous, which turned out to be a trenchant observation in light of later events.
•
Tyke, the elephant, walked back and forth. She didn’t seem particularly upset. Her trainer, Tyrone Taylor (one of very few African-American elephant trainers in the country) walked patiently with her. His demeanor and movements seemed unconcerned and relaxed.
Mr. Taylor was easy to spot that overcast day because he was wearing a bright red and gold Arabian-looking jacket. He fed Tyke carrots and apples from a bucket. When the elephant reached the end of the balcony, he would use a bullhook to turn her around.
A bullhook is a hooked metal rod that trainers use to guide elephants and sometimes to punish them. Animal activists say it is used abusively. Mr. Taylor seemed to be using it only for guidance.
The balcony was littered with elephant droppings and fragments of apples and carrots.
Each time Mr. Taylor tried to lead Tyke off the balcony, she would start to comply, then would back up. A few times, Mr. Taylor had Tyke lie down to demonstrate that he could control her.
It was unclear what had agitated her. One factor might have been the Jaffa Mosque’s doorways, which were too low for elephants. They had to crawl through them on their knees.
According to the circus owner, Tyke tried to rise too quickly and knocked the top of doorway, which startled her. She had run into the circus ring, according to witnesses, slapped a baboon with her trunk, then run outside, knocking out part of the mosque’s front doors. The audience of schoolchildren had evacuated the building as quickly as possible.
Luckily, nothing really came of the incident. Another elephant was used to lure Tyke back inside. The plan worked. No one was reported hurt (many years later, one of the schoolchildren said she’d been trampled but her injuries were kept out from the media). The damage was less than $15,000.
Yet the story upset me. I couldn’t help wondering whether Tyke had been abused. I read stories describing elephant abuse, and they shook me deeply.
•
A year went by. I was working at another newspaper when the news came across the wire. An elephant had gone on a rampage in Hawaii and had been shot to death with more than 85 bullets. The story was accompanied by a haunting photo of the elephant in profile, its eye wide with pain and fear as it was being shot. The elephant’s name … was Tyke.
Now, some film producers in Australia are making a documentary about Tyke, due out next year. (Anyone who has video or film of the Altoona incident may contact them at megan.mcmurchy@bigpond.com.) I’ve learned a bit about her, about how she was captured and about how the Altoona incident wasn’t the only warning sign she gave in the year before her fatal rampage.
I think about the elephant who killed a trainer at the Pittsburgh zoo in 2002. And I think about how I stood with my children next to an adolescent elephant at the Pittsburgh zoo and had our picture taken with it. I even touched the amazingly tough skin on its shoulder, something I don’t think the zoo keepers expected me to do.
Now I worry about that picture. What if I had startled the elephant? She had been small for an elephant and docile, but she was a lot bigger and stronger than I or anyone else was.
I’ve heard about problems that captive elephants have with their feet, which get infected from walking on hard, damp man-made surfaces. I’ve heard about orphaned baby elephants getting sunburned because the people caring for them didn’t know they needed protection from the sun. And I’ve heard about people hitting elephants with metal bars, among other nauseating “punishments.”
I love looking at elephants. But I am coming to the conclusion that they are not meant to be kept, and we are not meant to be their keepers. I just don’t know if we as a species can resist the temptation.
Laura Malt Schneiderman is a Web content producer for Post-Gazette.com (lschneiderman@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1923).





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.