Not that the transit-riding public needed this. But the latest evidence that Allegheny County bus and trolley riders are paying too much for service came Wednesday from the Pennsylvania Economy League of Southwestern Pennsylvania.
The findings by the league, an affiliate of the Allegheny Conference on Community Development, detail the cost of compensation for Port Authority union workers. They also mirror previous reports that show wages and benefits have gone beyond generous, have gone beyond handsome and may be approaching irresponsible for a public agency caught in a funding crisis that will take more than reduced service and higher fares to solve.
Since Pittsburgh hasn't seen a transit strike in 15 years, some riders may be wondering what's been the price of all this labor peace. After reading the Economy League data, it's easy to conclude that the price may have been too steep. Among the key findings:
• The system's bus drivers, at $23.30 an hour, have the highest top hourly wage of any metro area when adjusted for cost of living. (Without the adjustment, the wage is $22.18 an hour, 13th highest in the United States.)
• The Port Authority will spend $29.2 million on retiree health care this year -- four times as much as the $7.3 million spent by SEPTA, even though the Philadelphia-based system has three times as many employees.
• The health benefits package for the Port Authority's retired union employees is more generous than that of the system's nonunion workers and the union employees of Allegheny County, SEPTA and state government.
• All this comes at a cost. The Port Authority's liability for existing and future retiree health costs at the start of this year was $703.7 million, or twice the size of its annual budget. Compare that to the state's liability, which is much higher at $14 billion due to the number of employees but still only half of its budget.
These and other points in the Economy League summary will steel the resolve of county Chief Executive Dan Onorato to withhold the county's subsidy to the transit system until its financial house is in order. That means a real-world labor agreement is needed in 2008 -- and the sooner, the better.
The public can no longer sustain excessive pay, bloated health-care packages and retirement benefits awarded before retirement age. The 2,400 operators, mechanics and other employees represented by Local 85 of the Amalgamated Transit Union must be ready to bargain realistically for their next contract. This new report shows how unreal things have gotten.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.