President Donald Trump is backing away from the trade agreement the U.S. just announced with China, under pressure from China hawks among his supporters and in Congress who have assailed the accord as a capitulation.
"Our Trade Deal with China is moving along nicely, but in the end we will probably have to use a different structure in that this will be too hard to get done and to verify results after completion," Mr. Trump said in a Wednesday tweet, where he was both cryptic and subtle, raised questions and even acknowledged he might not know the answer.
Mr. Trump didn't specify what, exactly, he meant by "a different structure" or "too hard to get done," and White House officials didn't respond a request for clarification.
After boasting of the deal's benefits for farmers in tweets on Monday, Mr. Trump first indicated on Tuesday he was having second thoughts as some of his loyalists publicly criticized the agreement. Asked if he was pleased with the direction of his administration's negotiations with China, Mr. Trump told reporters "no, not really." He later added, "they're a start."
The president's misgivings open the prospect that a trade war Treasury Secretary Steven MMnuchin had declared "on hold" is at risk of resuming. Tariffs that Mr. Trump had proposed for $50 billion in Chinese goods are ready to be enacted at his command, after a public comment period expired on Tuesday. The Chinese have promised counter-tariffs targeting products from states politically important to Mr. Trump, particularly in the Midwest Farm Belt -- the source of intense pressure on the president to resolve the dispute.
But public criticism of the China deal by fellow Republicans and Trump supporters appears to be outweighing concern about a trade war among farm-state Republicans, retailers and others. Mr. Trump has also found himself under attack for retreating from penalties his administration announced against a large Chinese telecommunications company, ZTE Corp., for violating U.S. sanctions against Iran and North Korea.
Read More
"Sadly #China is out-negotiating the administration & winning the trade talks right now," Republican Sen. Marco Rubio of Florida tweeted on Tuesday. "They have avoided tariffs & got a #ZTE deal without giving up anything meaningful." He added, "This is #NotWinning," which plays off the president's signature catchphrases.
"#DoNotCave" Mr. Rubio tweeted Wednesday. "I don't understand how they can push for a deal that lets them keep operating in U.S.," he added.
Another critic of the deal, Sen. Steve Daines, R-Mont., lectured Mr. Mnuchin during a hearing at the Capitol on Tuesday.
"It's very important as we engage in these negotiations, we can't just see this as a standard trade dispute with China," Mr. Daines told the Treasury secretary. "We must keep in mind China's long-term strategic approach and their long-term goal of becoming the world's superpower, militarily and economically."
Trump supporters outside the government have joined in the chorus of complaints, and some have blamed Mr. Mnuchin.
"Doesn't make sense to have the Treasury secretary negotiating trade policy -- that's the USTR's job," former Nucor Corp. Chief executive officer Dan DiMicco said in a phone interview on Tuesday. Mr. DiMicco was an adviser to Mr. Trump's campaign and presidential transition who now sits on an advisory committee for U.S. Trade Representative Robert Lighthizer.
"We supported Trump in the elections, support a lot of the things he stands for, and we need him to come through on trade like he promised," Mr. DiMicco said.
Mr. Mnuchin announced Sunday the U.S. and China had agreed on a "framework" for trade talks, but neither nation provided any details of the agreement. While Mr. Trump said on Twitter that China had agreed to purchase "MASSIVE" amounts of American farm goods to reduce its yawning trade surplus with the U.S., the two sides didn't agree on a specific dollar figure.
Critics of the deal have also complained that it is silent on broader economic issues important to the U.S., including Chinese acquisition of American technology; the country's plans to subsidize growth of advanced domestic industries such as artificial intelligence and clean energy; and U.S. companies' access to China's markets.
Mr. Trump's about-face on ZTE adds to his allies' concerns. The Commerce Department announced April 16 that the company would be cut off from its U.S. suppliers, crippling its business, for what Commerce Secretary Wilbur Ross called "egregious" violations of U.S. sanctions. But Mr. Trump said on Tuesday that he had agreed to re-examine the matter as a personal favor to Chinese President Xi Jinping.
Mr. Trump said the U.S. may instead require that ZTE appoint a new board of directors and pay a "very large fine" of perhaps $1.3 billion.
The president’s apparent reflection on the state of fragile trade negotiations came after he has absorbed a bipartisan pounding from Democrats and Republicans who've warned he's being played and misled by Chinese leaders. Fourteen Republican senators including the party's second-ranking leader, John Cornyn of Texas, joined 13 Democratic and independent senators in sending Mr. Trump a public letter Tuesday urging him not to soften ZTE's punishment. They called ZTE's sanction violations "serial and pre-meditated."
"I'm not sure what to make of that," said Scott Paul, president of the Alliance for American Manufacturing, a partnership of labor groups and corporations. "The messages coming out over the past 10 days, it's like you are on a roller coaster going up and down and back and forth. It's hard to get any."
Others seemed to throw up their hands.
"Does anyone have the slightest idea what this means?" Edward Alden, a senior fellow at the Council on Foreign Relations, wrote on Twitter.
Mr. Ross plans to visit Beijing in early June to hammer out the details of the trade deal with China and how it would increase its purchases of American goods -- particularly of energy and farming products, his office said on Tuesday. A scheduled Mr. Ross appearance early Wednesday at a Heritage Foundation trade event in Washington was canceled, organizers said.
Some White House officials blamed poor coordination among the opposing factions on Mr. Trump's team for his initial agreement with China, according to several people briefed on the matter. Concern about harming negotiations over North Korea's nuclear program, in which China plays a pivotal role as the isolated nation's closest ally, has also factored in Mr. Trump's decision to hold off on tariffs.
Mr. Trump expressed doubt on Tuesday that his planned June 12 summit with North Korean leader Kim Jong Un would happen, telling reporters there's a "very substantial chance" it won't.
Mr. Mnuchin and White House economic adviser Larry Kudlow are free-trade supporters regarded as more conciliatory toward Beijing than Mr. Lighthizer and White House trade adviser Peter Navarro, the administration's fiercest China hawk. Mr. Mnuchin said in an interview on CNBC Monday that he speaks with Mr. Lighthizer 10 times a day and that he and the trade representative and Mr. Ross are "unified" on trade strategy.
He pointedly did not mention Mr. Navarro, with whom he quarreled during a trade mission to Beijing earlier this month.
The Washington Post contributed.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.