International trips are a ritual for every White House administration. They're supposed to showcase American leadership and influence, and are meant to reassure our allies that America is engaged with the world.
President Donald Trump's 12-day trip to Asia was no doubt meant to do the same. The president told reporters aboard Air Force One that "we've had a tremendously successful trip" that netted the US "at least $300 billion worth of deals." And on Wednesday, Trump said his trip showed that America’s “standing in the world has never been stronger.”
No doubt a significant portion of Americans agree with him, says The Economist's David Rennie.
"The half of the country that broadly supports what President Trump is doing ... saw a president being treated with fantastic amounts of pomp and flummery by the Chinese, or the Japanese or the Vietnamese," he says.
Trump was greeted by crowds of children cheering for him at the Beijing airport, a military ceremony in Vietnam and a red carpet event in the Philippines. "And so if you're a Trump supporter, you're looking at that and thinking, 'Great. This guy is doing exactly what he promised,'" says Rennie.
But if Americans were paying attention, Rennie thinks, they would have also seen some shocking things. For example, Trump praised the leader of the Philippines, President Rodrigo Duterte, who has sanctioned gunning down criminal suspects in the streets. Rennie says Duterte "is not just a bad guy. He boasts about being a killer. ... That normally would have gotten you some rebuke from an American president."
But no more. Rennie writes, "Not only does [Trump] admire dictators; he explicitly praises thuggishness, such as the mass murder of criminal suspects in the Philippines."
To Rennie, that's new. "That's really new."
And although other nations at the summit declared success toward salvaging the Trans-Pacific Partnership — a multilateral trade pact brokered by then-President Barack Obama and intended to counter China’s economic clout — Trump made no tangible progress on the one-on-one trade deals that he has promised as an alternative to sweeping multilateral pacts.
“If you are against the Chinese alone, China will fire back,” warned Michael Green, who was an Asia adviser to former President George W. Bush.
Also, as he wrapped up a marathon tour of Asia on Tuesday, Trump’s mixed messages left allies unsure of the United States’ staying power and fed a growing sense that China, not the United States, drives the agenda in the region.
Whether embracing China’s Communist leader at the same time that he promoted a “free and open Indo-Pacific,” or rallying partners to confront North Korea even as he warned that he was putting America first on trade, Trump was an often bewildering figure to countries that had already viewed this new president with anxiety.
These “internal contradictions have not been worked out,” said John Delury, an associate professor of Chinese studies at Yonsei University in South Korea. “Contrast that with the Chinese, who have this incredible consistency of message and are rising inexorably.”
On Thursday, China said it was sticking to its “freeze-for-freeze” proposal — which calls for North Korea to freeze its missile and nuclear tests in return for the United States and South Korea suspending their annual joint military exercises — to de-escalate tensions in the Korean Peninsula, contradicting a suggestion by Trump that it had turned against the plan.
James Acton, co-director of the nuclear policy program at the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace, said there was a lack of unity and clarity coming from the U.S. administration over what actions from North Korea might open the door to negotiations, what an acceptable path was to de-escalation, and even whether its ultimate goal was still regime change.
“One question is what would the preconditions be for the U.S. to sit down with North Korea to negotiate,” he said. “We’ve had at least three different answers to that question in the past week or two.”
Still, said Kurt Campbell, a former assistant secretary of state for East Asian affairs, “If this trip were a high-wire act, President Trump managed to get to the other side.”
After 12 hectic days in Asia, even Trump’s critics acknowledge he projected an air of engagement.
The question, they said, is whether his mixed messages will open the door further for China’s incursions in the region.
“Despite all the craziness of Trump, the U.S. remains in the game in Asia,” said Evan Medeiros, a former adviser to President Barack Obama on China. “But the U.S. is no longer driving the agenda.”
The New York Times, The Washington Post and Los Angeles Times contributed.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.