Simon Pringle of Hastings, England, believed he was a Scottish baronet, holder of a royal title bestowed on one of his ancestors by King Charles II in 1683 and handed down through generations of male heirs.
But that was before he had the royal carpet pulled out from under him recently by a second cousin and a DNA test, the first time a genetic sample has been used to determine hereditary aristocratic entitlement.
According to British news reports, Mr. Pringle —- one doesn’t have to call him “Sir Simon” any longer —- is a 56-year-old businessman, who was under the impression that with the 2013 passing of his father, the late Sir Steuart Pringle, he would become the 11th baronet of Stichill in the Borders. The baronetcy provides no land, property or wealth, but those who hold them value them.
That was why Murray Pringle, 74, an accountant from High Wycombe, began researching the Pringle surname in 2010, The Guardian reported. There had been scandalous rumors in the family that one of the males in the line of first-born sons was the offspring of an outsider.
The result was that Sir Steuart, at the age of 81, submitted a DNA sample that “did not match that of the Pringle lineage,” amounting to "a break in the line of paternity."
Disputed claims are rare these days. Queen Elizabeth II, citing legislation dating back more than 150 years, assigned the question to the Judicial Committee of the Privy Council, a seven-member panel of supreme court judges in Westminster in November.
“Clearly the interest of this case comes from a long tradition of secret heirs and lost inheritances,” said Alexander Chase-Levenson, an assistant professor in British history at the University of Pennsylvania in Philadelphia. “The DNA technology might be new, but the tradition of sensational stories where someone proves themselves to be a secret heir, upending assumptions and traditions, is an old one in British literature and culture. ... [It] seems true that if DNA could always have been used to rule on these kinds of cases, the drama, suspense, and excitement of many of them might have been lost. It would have been over and done with immediately if a simple DNA test could have proved the claimant was or wasn't the heir, and it wouldn't have made much news.”
On June 20, the Privy Council committee released its 25-page ruling — and expressed its deepest sympathies over the confusion.
As argued by Sir Murray’s lawyers, the lineage skewed in the early 20th century, after the death of Sir Norman Pringle, the eighth baronet, in 1919. Sir Norman and his wife, Florence, had three sons.
Or did they? The BBC reported that DNA evidence showed that Norman, the oldest child and the father of Sir Steuart, apparently was not the offspring of the baronet, despite a formal statutory declaration by his mother in 1920.
The Guardian said lawyers for Simon Pringle resisted Murray Pringle’s claim and questioned whether DNA evidence should be used to resolve the family dispute. They argued that the evidence should not be admitted on the grounds of “public policy.”
But the judges said the DNA evidence could not be ignored. It demonstrated to "a high degree of probability" that Norman could not have been the son of the eighth baronet and that there was no legal ground for excluding DNA evidence, they said.
Having eliminated the male descendants of Norman, the next in line was Norman’s younger brother, Ronald, the father of Murray, the man claiming the baronetcy.
Simon’s lawyers had argued that the ruling would affect the status of those who had died, but the council made no recommendation of rescinding anyone’s title. The unresolved and unaddressed question is whether Sir Murray is the 11th baronet or the ninth or 10th.
Pittsburgh attorney and forensic pathologist Cyril Wecht on Friday hailed the DNA finding as being appropriate.
“This kind of scientific evidence should prevail,” he said. “The only absolute forensic scientific testing procedure is cellular DNA.
“It was well known for centuries that, under English common law, they continued to say somebody was the father even though it could be shown that it was impossible, the ‘father’ was at sea or something. But they were making decisions based on familial tranquility, and they thought they were doing the right thing. I give this panel of justices credit for applying hard science. If it was something of an arguable nature, that is another matter. But when it comes to cellular DNA, there can be no question about its validity.
“This raises interesting questions. It cannot be easy, with all the fancy aristocracy over there in England with all their goings on about who is an earl or who is a baron. It could be used to test royal lineage. The question is, who is going to do it and for what purpose? It could be somebody just wants to write a book. You’d have to exhume the bodies of dead kings. And how would you get hold of DNA from the queen?”
Dr. Wecht noted the British tabloid contention that Prince Harry might not be the genetic son of Prince Charles. While the late American musician Prince was not of royal lineage, he died in April without children or a will, and there are a number of people claiming a genetic link to his $300 million fortune.
A Minnesota judge last week ruled that documents filed by some parties seeking DNA confirmation will be released July 11.
The Guardian reported that the Privy Council committee’s acceptance of DNA evidence in inheritance disputes, the justices said, could have far-reaching implications. “In the past,” they concluded, “the absence of scientific evidence meant that the presumption of legitimacy could rarely be rebutted and claims based on assertions that irregular procreations had occurred in the distant past were particularly difficult to establish.
“Not so now. ... DNA evidence [can] reopen a family succession many generations into the past. Whether this is a good thing and whether legal measures are needed to protect property transactions in the past, the rights of the perceived beneficiary of a trust of property, and the long established expectations of a family, are questions for others to consider.”
As far as Simon Pringle is concerned, there is no fortune or even a title. Only the honor of the Pringle name.
In a statement released through his solicitor, he said he had no complaints about the decision and welcomed Mr. Murray as the rightful successor.
"I want to congratulate Murray for winning the verdict and express the hope that he and his successors will wear the title as honorably as my father," he said.
Dan Majors: dmajors@post-gazette.com and 412-263-1456.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.