Rabbi Danny Schiff was quietly observing Shabbat — the Jewish Sabbath — in Pittsburgh when Prime Minister Yitzhak Rabin was assassinated in Israel, so he didn’t get the news until after nightfall, when his family turned on the news.
“I remember the tremendous shock and horror that we experienced, as did everyone else,” he said, noting that the Jew Ishmael’s slaying of Jewish regent Gedaliah 25 centuries ago is still mourned annually with a fast after Rosh Hashanah.
Mr. Rabin’s assassination is being remembered in Israel today, on its 20th anniversary according to the Hebrew calendar. Some observers view the killing as a pivot point in the 67-year-old country’s history, after which progress toward peace with the Palestinians withered in the face of violence and settlements. Rabbi Schiff, though, said it’s “too simplistic to think of 1995 as a turning point.”
There have been subsequent bids for compromise, he pointed out. And if the argument is that the assassination led to unprecedented political strife in Israel, that ignores thousands of years of tumult.
“It’s a Middle Eastern society. It’s a Jewish society,” he noted, as he sat in the lobby of the Hilton Garden Inn, in Oakland, a week after returning to Pittsburgh from Jerusalem. Debate, he noted with wry understatement, “is going to be robust.”
The Handshake and the Fists
Read More
Twenty years after an assassination changed the course of Israeli history, emigrants from the Pittsburgh region to the Holy Land live on all sides of the world's most intractable divide.
The Pittsburgh Post-Gazette's Rich Lord and Larry Roberts are in Israel this week, supported by the Pulitzer Center on Crisis Reporting, exploring the lives of ordinary people in this polarized place. Some of the people you'll meet here believe that familiarity can ease the anger between Arabs and Jews. A few who came in peace now cry for justice. Others are standing firm on land where it often rains stones.
Today, we'll look at Israel 20 years after the assassination of Prime Minister Yitzhak Rabin, who famously shook hands with Palestinian leader Yasser Arafat at the White House in 1993. Until then, follow Larry and Rich here every day as they bring images and stories from Israel's fault lines.
Follow along with the daily coverage.
Rabbi Schiff, an Australian, now 55, came to Pittsburgh in 1992 because his wife, Anne, was on the faculty of the University of Pittsburgh School of Law. They settled in Shadyside and he became a community scholar at the Agency for Jewish Learning, as well as White Oak’s rabbi.
In 2008, the family spent months in Jerusalem, a place he already knew well, but which proved exhilarating to Mrs. Schiff. In 2009, they moved to the Jerusalem neighborhood known as the German Colony.
Their son, David, was 14 and their daughter, Adina, was 12. “We expected some amount of turbulence, and we got it, but we got through it,” said Rabbi Schiff.
The kids got a taste of the liberty that characterizes an Israeli upbringing. “Naturally, it is an insecure place, but personally we let our kids walk around our Jerusalem neighborhood after dark in ways that we wouldn’t in Shadyside,” said Rabbi Schiff, in a comment echoed by other parents who moved from America to Israel.
He thinks the kids got something more important out of the move. “I think that when you live in Jerusalem,” he said, “you’re living in biblical time and space, and there’s something extraordinarily powerful about the sense of history and spirituality that you get there.”
Starting this month, he’s splitting his time between Jerusalem and Pittsburgh, as the Jewish Federation of Greater Pittsburgh’s scholar in charge of adult education.
The kids? “They’re both in the [Israeli] army now,” said Rabbi Schiff. They’re not in combat positions, but they are still at risk. “Anybody in uniform is a target. That creates some level of tension. But that is part of what it is to be an Israeli.”
Here, the escalating, near-daily shootings, stabbings and stone-throwing between Palestinians and Jews are just short news items. It’s different there. “When you’re in Israel, the air feels thick, the atmosphere feels heavy. People are downcast,” he said.
He trusts, though, that this won’t last forever. After all, the entire, troubled tenure of modern Israel is, so far, just a blip in Jewish history. “What’s 67 years?” he asked. “Most previous generations of Jews would be absolutely amazed to think that we would arrive at a time when we would be able to resurrect Jewish sovereignty in the land of Israel.”
Coming this afternoon: The commemoration of the 1995 assassination of Israeli Prime Minister Yitzhak Rabin
Rich Lord: rlord@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1542. Twitter @richelord





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.