As temperatures have struggled to climb above the teens for over a week, ice has accumulated rapidly on Pittsburgh’s waterways — but the Ohio, Monongahela and Allegheny rivers are not as solid as they might seem.

Beneath several inches of ice, water continues to flow at up to 3 mph.

That current poses dangers for people who try to walk out onto the river, said Alicia Miller, a hydrologist with the National Weather Service office in Moon.

The flow prevents the ice from forming uniformly and could trap a person under it if they fall in. 

Advertise with us

“There’s going to be pockets that are very thin or open, and if someone steps in the wrong place, they can go under,” she said. 

“And they’re not going to come back up.”

Simply put, walking onto river ice can quickly turn into a "life-threatening emergency,” the U.S. Coast Guard said.

But the risks haven’t stopped people from walking onto the rivers as temperatures dropped to dangerous lows.

Last month was the coldest January since 2014, according to the NWS, and clocked in at the 26th coldest January of all time in Pittsburgh, with an average temperature of 23.4 degrees.

Advertise with us

Officials said there have been reports of several individuals walking onto the ice this winter, including a man who fled from authorities onto the Allegheny River after he was caught trespassing at a former VA hospital site last week. 

“It's technically not illegal to walk on the ice, but it's highly advisable not to do so,” Pittsburgh Public Safety spokeswoman Emily Bourne said.

A stool sits on ice covering the Allegheny River adjacent to the North Shore on Monday. (Giuseppe LoPiccolo / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Health and safety concerns

Dr. David Barton, an assistant professor of emergency medicine at the University of Pittsburgh and an emergency physician at UPMC, said there are two primary risks of stepping onto the river’s ice: drowning and hypothermia.

“There’s definitely a widespread lack of recognition of the danger associated with it,” he said. “All it takes is a second for the ice to crack and someone to fall under — and then that could be a very tragic situation.”

The flow of the river is strong enough to pull people under the ice and prevent them from breaking loose, he said. 

Advertise with us

And those who are submerged but able to somehow stay at the surface can develop hypothermia, when abnormally low body temperature can affect brain functionality, according to the CDC. The water temperature in the three rivers is about 32 degrees, Ms. Miller said. 

While it takes about an hour for significant hypothermia to set in, Dr. Barton said, the impacts can start to be felt in minutes.

“After you reach that 10-minute mark, your body temperature is already dropping at least to a mild effect where you start to lose purposeful and coordinated movement of your extremities that affect your ability to swim,” he said.  

The same risks apply to first responders, too. 

“When someone goes through the ice, it can force first responders to conduct complex, high-risk operations in unstable conditions —placing rescuers at an elevated and unnecessary risk,” the Coast Guard said in a statement. 

Advertise with us
EMS Chief Amera Gilchrist speaks to reporters about the dangers of walking on the ice-covered rivers at EMS headquarters in Shadyside on Monday. (Pam Panchak / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Adding to the risk: It can take years for first responders to learn how to safely dive in the conditions Pittsburgh’s rivers are currently presenting, said Amera Gilchrist, chief of Pittsburgh EMS.

And even though the divers wear gear to protect against the frigid water temperatures, they can still experience hypothermia, she said.

“The risks associated are exactly the same as they are for someone who's not trained,” she said. “Don't put yourself in an unsafe position, and don't put them in an unsafe position, either.”

Dr. Barton recommends that anyone who finds themselves in a cold body of water take a minute to orient themselves during the immediate cold shock before swimming to shore as quickly as possible. 

Ice thaw and flooding risks ahead

The ice on the rivers will gradually thaw in the coming weeks, Ms. Miller said, unless there is heavy rain or a dramatic warm-up — neither of which is currently expected.

Advertise with us

The river levels also could rise from rain and melted snow, she said. But for that to happen, high and low temperatures would have to be above freezing for several days.

The average high temperature for February is 39 degrees, and the average low is 23. Temperatures have not exceeded 32 degrees since Jan. 22, according to NWS data.

With temperatures expected to stay below normal through at least the first half of February, Ms. Miller said continued ice growth is expected — although it’s still never safe to walk on.

“Because it is still flowing, it is also going up and down,” she said. “If it goes down, the ice doesn’t have anything to support it, so it’s like a gap.”

If the forecast takes a turn, rain and warmer temperatures could increase the risk of ice jams, she said, which would restrict the flow of water like a dam. The water that backs up could flood areas behind the jam, or flooding could also occur downstream if the ice breaks like a dam.

“The worst-case scenario [is] the ice gets all shoved out all at once,” she said. “Then we could have more widespread flooding.”