Though their candidates have questioned each other’s mental states, criticized one another fervently and — once upon a time — boasted about beating each other up, Republicans and Democrats in Pennsylvania say they want to see integrity, honesty and sincerity this Tuesday night when President Donald Trump and Joe Biden go one-on-one on the debate stage.
Pennsylvania voters — tasked, again, with possibly deciding the fate of an election in November — want to hear how the incumbent president and his Democratic challenger will lift them out of economic anguish and combat the COVID-19 pandemic, not what nicknames they have for each other and the quarrels that have become all too common in the era of today’s politics, officials and strategists from both sides of the aisle said in interviews this past week.
Mr. Trump’s style of off-the-cuff riffing and improvisational political theater isn’t a natural fit with traditional debate preparation, but to Charlie Gerow — a longtime Republican strategist in Pennsylvania who has prepared presidential, senatorial and gubernatorial candidates for debates dating back to the Ronald Reagan era — the president should just be himself.
Mr. Gerow said Mr. Trump also has to be measured in his back-and-forths with Mr. Biden, and should go out of his way to appear presidential and demonstrate that he’s “in command of the facts and has a clear agenda for the next four years.”
“Clearly, demonstrating the difference in energy and ability is important, but I think simply bashing Joe Biden all evening would not work that well,” Mr. Gerow said.
The temptation will be there, as the candidates haven’t exactly expressed admiration for each other. Mr. Biden once said he’d “beat the hell out of” Trump if they were in high school. Mr. Trump has said he’d win in a fight, has ruthlessly mocked Mr. Biden’s mental acuity and has said the former vice president is “against God.”
Read More
Mike Mikus, a Democratic strategist in Pittsburgh, said he’d encourage Mr. Biden to stay away from being “dragged into the mud” by Mr. Trump, insisting that voters want to hear about the issues.
“As we’ve seen over the years, when people engage in name calling and try to one-up [Mr. Trump] — Marco Rubio is probably the biggest example — you don’t win that battle,” Mr. Mikus said. “Where Joe Biden is going to win this is by focusing on the voters and not engaging in a back-and-forth with Donald Trump.”
Engaging in a battle of words and insults risks clouding a candidate’s message, said State Rep. Austin Davis, the former vice chair of the Allegheny County Democratic Committee. While Mr. Biden shouldn’t be afraid to punch back, he should focus on painting a clear and detailed image of how he’ll move the country forward,” Mr. Davis said.
“I think people know Donald Trump. They know what he’s about,” Mr. Davis said. “I don’t think we need to spend time litigating the last four years, because everybody knows who Donald Trump is and they have an opinion one way or another.”
Mr. Biden should specifically tailor his message to resonate with people in the Mon Valley, for example, who have not seen progress in the last three decades under Republican or Democratic administrations, Mr. Davis said.
The former vice president might get a chance to do that during one of the debate segments, focused on economic issues. There are five other segments, as of now: “The Trump and Biden Records,” the Supreme Court, COVID-19, “Race and Violence in our Cities” and “The Integrity of the Election,” according to news reports.
Allegheny County Executive Rich Fitzgerald, an early endorser of Mr. Biden, said he’d tell the candidate to go out of his way to correct the record — muddied by the president — on issues of fracking, taxation and criminal justice.
Mr. Biden also should hit the incumbent on his handling of COVID-19, Mr. Fitzgerald said, because it’s an issue that continues to impact everyone and one that he said the president has mismanaged.
Sam DeMarco, chair of the Republican Committee of Allegheny County, countered that “perfection doesn’t exist,” and that looking in hindsight at a virus that could have killed millions of Americans — but hasn’t, under Mr. Trump’s leadership — is unfair.
The GOP chair said Mr. Trump should use the debate to have a conversation with the American people about his record of action — one that should earn him another term — and explain to people who he is and why he acts the way that he does.
If he explains to people why he’s perceived as confrontational sometimes, they’ll buy it, Mr. DeMarco said.
If Mr. DeMarco were the president on Tuesday, he’d say, “Hey, look, I understand this may turn some folks off but you have to understand, I’m under attack 24 hours a day, seven days a week, from everybody, and I’m just trying to show folks that you need to fight back,” he said.
Mr. Gerow said he expects Mr. Biden to blame the president for “everything under the sun,” and make a case, by definition, that he’s simply not Mr. Trump — hoping that’s enough to sway persuadable and undecided voters. He said it’s a “legitimate concern” for Republicans that the media will declare Mr. Biden the winner for only exceeding the “low bar” that’s been set for him — mostly because of Mr. Trump’s constant attacks on his mental acuity.
Mr. Mikus said Democrats are excited about that prospect.
“I think that the Trump campaign, over the past few months, has made a critical strategic error in how they portrayed Joe Biden,” Mr. Mikus said. “They lowered the bar for Joe Biden. If he’s able to clear that bar — which I’m very confident he will — I think it will be a successful debate.”
Republicans underestimated Mr. Biden in 2012, Mr. DeMarco said, when they thought Paul Ryan would “wipe the floor” with him in the vice presidential debate.
The key is to stay focused, Mr. DeMarco said of Mr. Trump.
“Trump may want to trigger him, but I wouldn’t get into a battle with him,” Mr. DeMarco said. Instead, Mr. Trump should say that he delivered promises for the American people, Mr. DeMarco added.
Is Mr. DeMarco confident Mr. Trump can do that on Tuesday?
“No,” Mr. DeMarco said, laughing.
“The one thing I learned about this president: he’s going to do what he wants to do,” he said.
Julian Routh: jrouth@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1952, Twitter @julianrouth.







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.