HARRISBURG — That morning more than 23 years ago, state Rep. Kerry Benninghoff flashed his state ID to get into a building in Harrisburg and — in a surprise to him — he was denied access and told it was “an issue of national security.”

A little later, watching television, he saw one of the World Trade Center towers collapse.

Such etched-in-memory moments from the Sept. 11, 2001, terrorist attacks remain the ultimate context for the ongoing crowds of people at PennDOT driver license centers seeking a Real ID. The commission that investigated the attacks recommended standards for sources of identification like driver’s licenses – and in 2005, the Real ID Act became federal law.

Resistance by states, deadline extensions, and built-in options have muddied public understanding and diluted compliance. Wednesday, however, constitutes a firm federal deadline.

Advertise with us

A Real ID or another federally accepted document — like a passport or a military ID — will be required from that day forward to board flights or enter certain federal facilities. A traditional Pennsylvania driver’s license will no longer work for those purposes.

At the same time, that standard-issue Pennsylvania driver’s license remains available and is sufficient for driving.

Long lines of Real ID-seekers have formed at some of PennDOT’s 57 driver’s license centers. On Thursday, Transportation Secretary Mike Carroll said staffers were working six days a week to accommodate the crush.

One reason for those lines, Mr. Carroll said, was human nature. “A lot of folks have waited until the last minute,” he said.

The other reason, he said, was the optional nature of involvement for Pennsylvanians, laid out by a state law passed in 2017. Other states — like Georgia — have required drivers to upgrade to Real ID.

Advertise with us

Mr. Benninghoff has watched Pennsylvania lawmakers grapple with questions for nearly two decades.

“I think a lot of people in the General Assembly didn’t want people to think we were forcing them,” Mr. Benninghoff said.

The 2005 federal law was controversial as soon as it was passed. The American Civil Liberties Union, a staunch opponent, noted it was not subjected to hearings or debate.

In Pennsylvania, on June 25, 2008, then-Rep. Gordon Denlinger, a Republican, told fellow House members during a debate on a proposed amendment to a Real ID bill of his concern that “governments do not always use data for good ends.”

Mr. Denlinger said, “Who is to say what facial images collected on the citizens of this State could be turned into when a government turns against its own citizenry?”

Advertise with us

Four years later, in a different Real ID debate, state Rep. Greg Vitali, D-Delaware, said he struggled with the Real ID concept. His primary concern, he said, was a single extremist “who secures some fissionable nuclear material, brings it into a large metropolitan area like downtown Manhattan, detonates that nuclear material and renders that island uninhabitable for many years to come and results in the death of tens of thousands of people.”

In 2012, the Legislature passed a bill that was signed into law by then-Gov. Tom Corbett. It forbid the governor or any state agency from participating “in the compliance of any provision of the REAL ID Act of 2005.”

Five years later, that law was repealed. It was replaced by a let-residents-decide approach, sponsored by Sen. Kim Ward, R-Westmoreland.

That approach, which was signed into law by then-Gov. Tom Wolf on May 26, 2017, still stands. It gives residents the option of asking PennDOT for a standard-issue driver’s license, or bringing a required set of documents to PennDOT and asking for an enhanced-security Real ID.

The longest-serving member of the state House, Democratic Rep. Robert Freeman of Northampton County, said that after the original mandate from the federal government, there were a number of extensions. That, combined with Pennsylvania’s “optional approach,” has muddied the water for people.

Advertise with us

“There were starts and stops,” he said. “There were a lot of mixed messages.”

Mr. Benninghoff said he is trying to ease the process with a bill that was passed by the House last week. The bill expands the number of documents that can be used to apply for a Real ID, and it will next be considered by the Senate.

Mr. Carroll said PennDOT has been offering Real ID’s for years.

The May 7 deadline, he noted, was set by the federal Transportation Security Administration and not PennDOT. For those people who want a Real ID but don’t have immediate travel plans — or already have a Passport — Mr. Carroll had advice.

He said, “You may want to hold off for a few weeks until the rush at the driver license centers dies down.”