As Pittsburgh enters the coldest weeks of winter, the precipitation on its rugged topography has once again made driving on its roads feel like rock climbing without a harness.
The City of Pittsburgh has tried to address the situation by shutting down many of its steepest streets at the first sign of snow. For at least the second time this winter, the city closed the same six roads earlier this week in anticipation of what forecasters had said could be up to 5 inches of snow overnight Sunday and throughout Monday: South Negley Avenue in Squirrel Hill, Rialto Street in Troy Hill, Suffolk Street in Perry South, Newett Street and Copperfield Avenue in Carrick, and Capital Avenue in Brookline.
The storm ended up dropping mostly 2 inches or less within city limits.
The city chose to close those streets based on historic crash data from public safety during winter weather events, in consultation with Public Works, according to Department of Public Works Director Chris Hornstein. Aside from steepness, the city considers factors such as surface type, street condition, traffic volume, public usage, existing traffic control devices, and potential accident hazards, he said.
The Post-Gazette visited these streets to see just how dangerous they can be in snowy weather and how neighbors deal with them.
One note on a road that Pittsburghers might be surprised to see is not on the list — Canton Avenue, considered one of the steepest roads in the world. This is because traffic volume is low, so public safety has not made any requests to close it in recent years, said Mr. Hornstein. Besides, large “Do Not Enter” signs discouraging downhill travel are posted at the top of the hill year-round, he said.
Read More
“Public Works believes residents are familiar with the area,” he said.
View this post on Instagram
South Negley Avenue
South Negley Avenue is one of the main arteries connecting Shadyside and Squirrel Hill. The road traverses a bridge and is mostly flat, but it rises dramatically just beyond the stoplight at the intersection of Fifth Avenue — and that’s where danger can lie.
A slippery layer of sleet covered parts of the sidewalk and street in the steepest section of South Negley on Wednesday. The road was closed as crews completed a weeks-long People’s Gas pipeline repair that had previously only partially restricted access.
Justin Guglilmotti, a flagger for local traffic control service ALL Ways Safe, was standing in the intersection in front of a barricade diverting befuddled drivers since early that morning.
“This is always the worst time of the year,” he said with a wry grin.
At the top of the hill, Mr. Guglilmotti’s counterpart, Matthew Gill was patiently relaying to each car that the road was closed. He lifted a lingering piece of caution tape to allow them to cut perpendicular across the top of the hill.

After helping yet another driver, Mr. Gill gestured to the construction site down the hill and acknowledged that it was his responsibility to prevent a disaster.
“What if he started sliding sideways right there?” he said about one of the drivers.
Mr. Gill said he had been approached by several concerned citizens who live on the street throughout the day who asked him how they were supposed to access essentials and emergency services because they couldn’t get off of the street.
“All I see is problems on this hill,” he said. “I can’t really think of anything good to say about it, honestly.”
Standing in his driveway adjacent to the construction, resident David Kozloff, 74, said the city closing his stretch of South Negley was a good thing, even though it blocked him from his physical therapy appointment. In the past, drivers tried to brave the road and frequently wiped out in his neighbors’ yards, he said.

“I’m always surprised people come down this hill when it’s snowing … you don’t have a chance,” he said.
Between weather and construction, South Negley ping-ponged between open and closed this week. It was closed on Monday, open on Tuesday, closed on Wednesday, and open again Thursday.
Rialto Street
Rialto Street, leading up to the Troy Hill neighborhood on the North Side, is one of the few roads within the city limits that is not lined with houses. That doesn’t make it any less treacherous for drivers during the winter — the street plunges straight down from the top of Troy Hill and terminates off-center of 31st Street, meaning that drivers have to make an awkward right turn to continue going straight.
Thankfully for locals, Rialto isn’t the only way in and out of the neighborhood. As she scraped ice off of her driveway near the mouth of the street, resident Helen Straka said she avoided Rialto and instead used the much gentler Troy Hill Road to get where she needs to go, like Giant Eagle and Kuhn’s Market.
With an alternate route available, Ms. Straka’s reasoning for avoiding Rialto’s steep drop was simple: “What occasion do I have to go down there for?”
Suffolk Street
Suffolk Street, a short drive from Rialto Street in Perry South, emerges from under I-279 and winds past around a dozen houses on its way up.
Eric Vearnon, 55, has lived in one of the homes clinging to the hill along Suffolk for 15 years.
Mr. Vearnon hadn’t seen the salt boxes the city used to leave out for residents to treat the road themselves so far this year, but Mr. Hornstein said the city added salt boxes to Suffolk on Friday.
Mr. Vearnon has grown to love his “wonderful” neighborhood, but he worries for his safety every time he sees snow in the forecast. The street often deals with car crashes, and emergency vehicles would struggle to reach him if he needed help, he said.
“I go to the grocery store, I go to the hardware store, and I’m prepared. I have to be on this street,” he said.

City spokesperson Olga George urged drivers to avoid driving around barricades at streets like Suffolk.
“When accidents happen, and you're saying the street wasn't salted, there was a barricade to prevent that from happening,” Ms. George said Friday.
Southern Neighborhoods
Newett Street and Copperfield Avenue are positioned side-by-side in Carrick, sloping three blocks from the neighborhood branch of the Carnegie Library to a pair of baseball fields. When the streets close in the winter, they can also affect access in and out of the four perpendicular streets that connect them.
Not far away is Capital Avenue, a road made of thick, chunky stones that curves through the Brookline neighborhood and ends in front of Fiori's Pizzaria at the bottom of the hill. Fiori’s cashier Jamie Walter said the restaurant’s business wasn’t affected when the road was closed since it borders the much busier W. Liberty Avenue., but he has seen people sledding down the steep road during heavy snowfalls.
Frequent diner John Fiori, of Dormont, said he took W. Liberty Avenue instead of Capital Avenue because it is uneven and freezes during the winter.
Mr. Fiori, a Navy veteran who was once stationed in Italy, remarked he’d rather drive on a Roman-built block road than Capital Avenue.
“You’d lose your tailpipe, your engine would fall out,” he said, mimicking a rumbling noise. “You’re gonna bounce like a rabbit.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.