Nothing has come easy to Tracy Hager over the past year. And even when something promising arises, it comes with stipulations. 

The $600 million settlement reached with Norfolk Southern for damage from the Feb. 3, 2023 East Palestine train derailment is no different. Late Tuesday, a Youngstown district judge approved the agreement, setting the stage for residents to begin claiming a portion of the funds.

Over a year after the disaster, the financial costs continue to strain her family. She and her husband are shelling out thousands of dollars to fix up their home, which was covered in black soot after the derailment and the planned explosion of five railcars that came a few days later. But she isn’t banking on the settlement to bring relief. 

“I don't know with how everything is set up if it’s going to function for half the people in town,” Ms. Heger said. 

Advertise with us

Anyone who lived, worked or owned a business within 20 miles of the train derailment after Feb. 3 is eligible for the direct payments, which could be split between thousands of people. 

And certain factors, such as location, acreage, the length of displacement and the nature of the property damage, will carry weight and determine how much each household receives. 

Those who live within 10 miles of the derailment can choose to receive additional compensation for health effects they’ve experienced, so long as they agree to not pursue any damages in Norfolk in the future. 

For Ms. Heger, one of the most frustrating aspects is that money she took to help her family recuperate, buy essentials and pay for a camper to temporarily live in after the derailment, would affect the final amount she sees from the settlement. 

Norfolk Southern has provided more than $21 million in direct assistance to families who had to temporarily relocate. The reimbursement payments residents took will be taken out of their final settlement checks. 

Advertise with us

She’s also unsure what kind of paperwork she would have to submit to show what Norfolk Southern gave her. For housing alone, she relied on the company to help cover the costs for about seven months. 

“I just don't see where this is fair,” Ms. Hager said. “This whole suit is not fair.”

Later this month, a neutral third-party administrator, Kroll Settlement Administration, LLC will send emails and letters to all class members informing them of the claims process. The group will also create a website to provide more information. 

The claims assistance center will be located at the former site of the Norfolk Southern Family Assistance Center at 191 East Rebecca St. in East Palestine. It will be open starting on the first business day after notices are mailed out by the end of the month. 

Residents have about six weeks, until July 1, to decide whether or not to opt out. 

Advertise with us

“We know many residents, employees and business owners have questions about this process,” a statement from the law firms representing residents wrote. “We want them to know: we hear you … We are confident that the court will ultimately find during the Final Approval process that the settlement is a fair, reasonable and adequate resolution to the litigation.”

Jami Wallace sees the outcome much differently. She doesn’t think it delivers much justice at all. 

Based on averages shown in court documents, the payments will be far ranging. Households within less than 2 miles of the derailment may receive as much as $70,000, and those within 15 to 20 miles could see as little as $250. Since the derailment, she has moved from East Palestine to East Liverpool, about 17 miles away. 

“Even if you divided it up evenly, we're going to be in the same situation we're in now where we’re not even going to have enough money to properly test our homes,” Ms. Wallace said. 

Help has already been hard to come by. Ohio Gov. Mike DeWine was slow to ask the federal government for aid, waiting until the summer. Residents have said that reimbursement payments from Norfolk Southern were inconsistent. President Joe Biden hasn’t issued a major disaster declaration, which would unlock more federal resources for the reeling community. 

Advertise with us

And still, the cleanup of the toxic disaster is not over, and residents are waiting on key answers from the National Transportation Safety Board, which has been investigating the accident. 

Less than a week before they must file paperwork to opt out of the suit, NTSB will return to East Palestine on June 25 for its final board meeting on the derailment.

“Our creeks are still heavily contaminated,” Ms. Wallace said. “You know, people are still being exposed. We don't even have the NTSB final results from their hearing. It just seems really premature.”

And this isn’t just a choice she’s making for herself. If one person in a household decides not to participate in the settlement, that goes for everyone else, too.

“How do you make that decision as a parent?” she said. 

The final approval hearing is scheduled for Sept. 25. If all goes to plan, attorneys representing the residents could receive their checks from the settlement by the end of the year.