The announcement of a $600 million settlement for damage caused by the 2023 Norfolk Southern train derailment in East Palestine, Ohio, has, for some, brought more questions than answers.
Earlier this week, the company, which has already shelled out hundreds of millions in community recovery funds, announced it had agreed to the deal to settle a yearlong class-action lawsuit.
On Wednesday, the attorneys who reached the deal on behalf of residents coping with fallout from the derailment couldn’t say how many people will be splitting the millions, as anyone in the community of roughly 5,000, as well those living within 20 miles of the derailment site, are eligible to file a claim.
The legal team also couldn’t say what percentage of the money will go toward attorney fees, which is up to the judge to decide.
Mike Morgan, an attorney with Morgan & Morgan in Orlando, Fla., called the settlement an “outstanding” resolution for East Palestine and residents of surrounding communities who have suffered the consequences of the toxic disaster.
“This $600 million resolution is going to go 100% directly back to the community,” he said.
Read More
If approved, the settlement will resolve all consolidated cases brought before the federal court in Youngstown, Ohio.
It will take months to resolve the case, but payments could come by the end of the year. The money could be used for health care needs and medical monitoring, property restoration and compensation for any business loss.
The train that derailed Feb. 3, 2023, was carrying toxic materials, including substances used to make plastic products. The derailment resulted in a jumble of burning rail cars, and contamination of the community’s air, land and water. Residents living near the derailment site were evacuated.
The attorneys said a fair distribution system was developed to ensure that those most affected by the derailment receive the compensation they deserve. Certain factors, such as proximity to the derailment site, will carry more weight.
The attorneys also clarified the payment distribution process, which has yet to be finalized on paper. The money will be administered for those living within 10 miles of the derailment first, and then those living between 10 and 20 miles away from the site. Business owners who can prove that they lost money as a result of the incident can also receive compensation.
“This isn't as simple as saying $600 million divided by X number of people, and everybody gets the same,” said Elizabeth Graham of the law firm Grant & Eisenhofer, which has offices in Chicago, New York, San Francisco, Baltimore and Wilmington, Del.
The $600 million agreement includes a voluntary program to compensate people for past, present and future personal injuries resulting from exposure to the chemicals involved.
In exchange for the money, though, those individuals cannot file any lawsuits against Norfolk Southern in the future, even decades from now if they develop serious health conditions, Ms. Graham said.
She said this is because the risks posed by the chemicals, according to their experts, aren't as “great as we feared.” But those who wish to put the money in a trust can do so, which could help pay for medical costs in the future.
“If there are individuals who, unfortunately, do get sick, it will be years from now, so the payment would cover those future expenses,” she said.
Other factors include how close someone lived to the derailment, and to the site of the venting and burning of the chemicals in the derailed cars, which occurred days later. Household composition is also a factor, with priority going to people with children.
“It's a fair and impartial process that is designed to compensate folks who were affected the most with the highest values,” Ms. Graham said.
Norfolk Southern still faces legal action brought by state and federal agencies for the environmental cleanup.
One of those cases is from Ohio Attorney General Dave Yost, who filed a 58-count lawsuit in federal court in March 2023 in an effort to hold Norfolk Southern financially responsible for “recklessly endangering” the health of residents and Ohio’s natural resources.
The suit cites the railroad company’s escalating accident rate, which has risen 80% over the past 10 years. At least 20 Norfolk Southern derailments since 2015 have involved chemical discharges.
Following a February order requiring the company to develop and implement plans to address contamination and pay for response costs, the federal Environmental Protection Agency also sued Norfolk Southern for its role in the environmental catastrophe.
The $600 million settlement now awaits a judge’s approval. If granted, community members will have a set period of time to file claims. Ms. Graham said this process won’t require them to hire a lawyer and, if all goes as planned, the goal is to send the checks out by the end of the year.
As confidential negotiations went on for months with mediator Seth Katz, a Colorado-based attorney for Burg Simpson Eldredge Hersh & Jardine, it came down to hearing what the residents wanted.
“We spoke with them, what was important for them, what were their concerns,” he said. “We know that they're all very supportive, very happy, and think this is a fantastic outcome to happen so quickly.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.