In the throes of Pittsburgh’s financial crisis in 2014, auditors issued a stern warning to local officials: Fix the aging Charles Anderson Bridge — a major span stretching from Oakland to Schenley Park — or it could be shut down and force detours on 20,000 motorists each day.

But the critical repairs were never performed on the 86-year-old bridge, even as the rusting underside and deck continued to deteriorate.

Nine years later, the predictions came true. With the superstructure at risk of “imminent failure,” local officials closed one of the most well-traveled thoroughfares in the city.

While much has been written about the city’s failures leading up to the collapse of the Fern Hollow Bridge two years ago, the lack of response by local officials to the alarms about the Charles Anderson exposes a deeper problem impacting scores of bridges in nearly every corner of the city.

Advertise with us

In bridge after bridge, records show the city has failed repeatedly to respond to inspectors’ alerts that major repairs and fundamental safeguards needed to be implemented.

At the Larimer Bridge, hunks of concrete began to break off and fall.

At the Swindell Bridge, inspectors found the floor beams so corroded that deep holes punctured the surface.

The 28th Street Bridge, a major artery for travel between Polish Hill and the Strip District, received repairs in 2019, but debris was still falling from the span a year later, inspectors noted.

“We need to be more proactive,” state Sen. Jay Costa, D-Allegheny, said. “We’ve got to find out where our problem bridges are and not wait for something to happen to address it.”

Advertise with us
The 28th Street Bridge, a major artery for travel between Polish Hill and the Strip District, received repairs in 2019, but debris was still falling from the span a year later, according to inspectors. (Lucy Schaly / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Yearslong wait for repairs

While Mayor Ed Gainey and other officials have bolstered their bridge oversight — the city added new funding for maintenance and introduced five new positions to the Bridges and Structures Division to tend to the iconic structures — Pittsburgh is now faced with the specter of repairing 22 bridges rated in poor condition, the same number as when Fern Hollow crumbled to the ground.

“The Fern Hollow Bridge for many Americans was a wakeup call for something we already know all too well, which is over the last half-century, America allowed its critical infrastructure to deteriorate,” U.S. Transportation Secretary Pete Buttigieg said during a press conference Wednesday.

While all bridges need periodic repairs — and sometimes replacements — experts say the lack of a rigorous maintenance program may have set Pittsburgh back years in addressing its most urgent infrastructure needs.

So far, the city is only positioned to carry out one major renovation this year: The Charles Anderson. Several bridges rated in poor condition won't undergo renovations for five years or longer, and each bridge can take a year or more to be fully rehabilitated as the costs of repairs climb.

For the Larimer Bridge, city officials had to install netting to stop chunks of the underside from tumbling down onto the four-lane Washington Boulevard below. The span isn’t scheduled to undergo major repairs until 2026.

Advertise with us

The Lowrie Street Bridge, also rated poor, isn’t scheduled for fixes until 2032.

The Ansonia Bridge, which stretches over the heavily trafficked Route 51, has been shut down because of structural deficiencies for more than seven years and it will be another seven years before it gets a major renovation.

Further aggravating the problem is that the more time that passes — with traffic pounding the structures — the greater probability the bridges will require more extensive work.

The cost will be steep: a private consultant hired by the city estimated that urgent repairs could cost up to $11.7 million, and renovations for several of the city’s aging bridges could total in the hundreds of millions, bogging down taxpayers for generations, records and interviews show.

“When you don’t have the resources, you don’t have the resources,” Mr. Costa said. “That’s the problem.”

Advertise with us

“When you don’t have the resources, you don’t have the resources. That’s the problem.”

Costly upgrades

In the years since the Fern Hollow collapse, Mr. Gainey has increased the city’s budget for bridge upgrades from about $750,000 when he first took office to about $4.75 million in 2023. The city is also expected to receive about $3.6 million from the Southwestern Pennsylvania Commission for the Bridge Preservation and Restoration Fund this year. But those funds will barely dent the amount of money that will be needed to tackle all of the breakdowns in city bridges.

The Charles Anderson rehab alone is expected to cost $27 million.

Before it closed, Emmett Henderson, a Greenfield resident, said he would take that bridge to his job as a researcher at the University of Pittsburgh.

Mr. Henderson said that when Fern Hollow fell, his colleagues weren’t surprised. Typical Pittsburgh infrastructure, they said. “That in itself is a bad sign,” he said.

Advertise with us

Two years later, Mr. Henderson said he’s disappointed by the city’s failure to address the nearly two dozen bridges in poor condition.

“You’d think that would’ve sounded the alarm a little bit.” he said.

In the case of Fern Hollow, inspectors repeatedly told the city to clean out the drainage systems and make sure the surface water and salt was not seeping into the underbelly of the span, an engineer for CDM Smith told National Transportation Safety Board investigators. And every year, most of the warnings were never acted on by the city, emails show.

The same situation has happened with other city bridges. Take the case of the Swindell Bridge that soars high over Parkway North.

Year after year, inspectors found serious structural deficiencies. In 2020, there was heavy rusting and corrosion — mostly from a deteriorating water drainage system — and “fracture critical” areas of the deck. The following year, inspectors discovered rampant holes and leaky joints.

Advertise with us
City officials allocated no money for the Swindell Bridge in this year’s budget, but future projections show about $3.1 million going to the bridge next year and $8 million in 2026. (Lucy Schaly / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

The 94-year-old span had to be closed for two months in 2022, after construction work on the bridge caused debris to fall onto the busy highway below. Last year, it was shut down again while crews restored about $540,000 worth of deteriorated steel beams.

“When they work on this bridge, they only do patch work,” said Dre Wilson, an employee at Wilson’s Bar-B-Q in Perry South. “Everytime they fix something you come back and there’s another hole.”

City officials allocated no money for the Swindell Bridge in this year’s budget, but future projections show about $3.1 million going to the bridge next year and $8 million in 2026. Most of the money for Pittsburgh’s bridge repairs comes from state and federal sources, through the Southwestern Pennsylvania Commission.

Corrosion ‘a cancer’ on bridges

For dozens of bridges across the city, inspectors say the most damaging oversight mistake is failing to clean the clogged drainage systems, which can give way to rust.

“The number one problem was the clog scuppers and downspouts on almost all their bridges,” Tim Pintar, who inspected Fern Hollow and several other Pittsburgh bridges over the years, told NTSB investigators.

Advertise with us

When drainage systems aren’t cleaned out at least annually, corrosion can set in within three to four years. And once corrosion begins, experts say, it’s nearly impossible to stop.

“Longterm, it can destroy” a bridge, said Roberto Leon, professor of civil and environmental engineering at Virginia Tech. “I would characterize it almost as a cancer. We have treatments for cancer, but there are certain cancers that don’t respond very well to treatment.”

The underside of the Anderson Bridge is covered with rust, a sign of corrosion, according to Mr. Leon. Construction bids for a full rehabilitation of the bridge are scheduled to go out in February, and the bridge is tentatively set to reopen in the Fall of 2026.

The Charles Anderson Bridge in Oakland is slated to undergo major renovations this year. The repair is expected to cost $27 million. (Lucy Schaly / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

The Panther Hollow Overpass, which sits just a few hundred yards down the street from the Anderson bridge, has also been included in the redesign to fix problems that would have resulted in the posting of a weight limit on the overpass.

But in fixing those bridges, another bridge slated for a complete reconstruction has been delayed.

Advertise with us

In July 2022, the city announced the Swinburne Bridge, which connects Greenfield and Hazelwood to Downtown, would undergo a complete reconstruction.

But when the Charles Anderson Bridge was unexpectedly closed, city officials raised concerns about the traffic impact of having both closed at the same time due to their proximity. The original timeline from the city had construction starting on the Swinburne bridge this year, but now, a bid for work won’t go out until February 2025.

The cost of upkeep

Time and money are some of the biggest hindrances in fixing bridges.

Because of that, cities often carry out short-term fixes rather than major overhauls, but that “creates more problems than it solves,” said Hota GangaRao, an engineering professor at West Virginia University.

The small repair jobs work in the short-term, but eventually a large renovation will be needed and could take longer and be more costly than if the bridge was completely fixed the first time, he added.

Advertise with us

Over the next decade Pittsburgh is expected to receive about $202.6 million from the SPC for bridge repairs. But the bulk of that money won’t be seen until 2027 or later, as long as priorities remain the same. And there are no guarantees the city will get the money.

Over the next decade Pittsburgh is expected to receive about $202.6 million from the SPC for bridge repairs. But the bulk of that money won’t be seen until 2027 or later, as long as priorities remain the same. And there are no guarantees the city will get the money.

The SPC manages the Regional Transportation Improvement Program (TIP) which outlines the region’s “highest priority transportation projects” and is updated every two years.

With less than half the city’s poorly rated spans scheduled for extensive repairs by local officials and the SPC, the length of time it could take for Pittsburgh's dilapidated bridges to be upgraded could be 20 years or longer.

Even if the city has created its own schedule for repairs, it still must wait in line with other jurisdictions for the state and federal funding.

Advertise with us

Top priority is not always determined by bridges in the worst condition, but by what projects local representatives lobby for. PennDOT officials have previously said that if local officials want to bump a bridge up the list for repairs, they can press to get the work done.

Those needs could change though, depending on who is in office and what the status of the infrastructure is at the time.

“What we have to do is prioritize the ones that are in the most immediate need to make them maintain their safety and work our way through that process by doing assessments of their condition,” Mr. Costa said.

Laura Esposito, Mike Wereschagin and Jonathan D. Salant contributed to this report.

Hallie Lauer: hlauer@post-gazette.com; Neena Hagen: nhagen@post-gazette.com