HARRISBURG — The Interstate 95 overpass bridge collapse is a warning call about the consequences of other bridge failures in Pennsylvania, according to a study of PennDOT released earlier this month by a legislative research agency.
“The bridge was relatively new as it was just 10 years old,” said the study by the Legislative Budget and Finance Committee (LBFC) referring to the accident involving a gas tanker truck in June. “Consequently, while the I-95 incident may be genuinely an accident, not the result of a bridge in poor condition or considered structurally deficient, the I-95 emergency offers a warning for other Pennsylvania bridges and the life-cycle costs.”
With estimates of the I-95 repair between $25 million to $30 million, the study warns that allowing bridges to age without proper maintenance or reconstruction has an immense public cost that can put strains on traffic, taxpayers and the economy. Pennsylvania has 1,267 bridges rated in poor condition with 8.3% of state-owned bridges listed in poor condition.
The purpose of the study is to compare PennDOT’s performance with selected “peer” states (Delaware, Georgia, Illinois, Maryland, Michigan, Missouri, New Jersey, New York, Ohio and West Virginia).
Among the peer states, Pennsylvania has the highest percentage of bridges older than 50 years and a higher proportion of structurally deficient bridges.
Pennsylvania also ranks worse than the national average for the percentage of roads in poor condition.
The peer comparisons must be weighed with a nod to several long-standing characteristics about Pennsylvania transportation, the study said.
They include having 45,000 miles of state-owned highways, a mountainous geography and challenging weather with freeze-thaw cycles that cause potholes.
And Pennsylvania has more registered motorists than the peer states, and significantly, the most truck registrations of those states.
An interesting finding is that while a truck axle carrying 18,000 pounds is only nine times heavier than a 2,000-pund automobile axle, the truck axle does 5,000 times more damage to roads than the automobile axle.
Pennsylvania’s status as the “Keystone State” has long meant that its transportation corridors (canals, railroads and highways) carried interstate traffic. In recent years, this has manifested itself in the development of warehouses along Pennsylvania interstates, especially Interstate 81 and Interstate 78.
“Pennsylvania is home to many Fortune 500 distribution and fulfillment centers,” the study said. “As a result, with easy access to major interstates such as I-80 and I-95, Pennsylvania’s roads see some of the highest usage by trucks country-wide.”
Pennsylvania has a funding gap of $8.1 billion for road and bridge projects, a circumstance aggravated by trends showing the gasoline tax — the primary revenue source for the state Motor License Fund — is less reliable because vehicles have become more fuel efficient and the number of electric vehicles on the road has increased.
Most peer states rely on the gas tax for 50% or less of total transportation revenue, while in Pennsylvania more than 70% is from the gas tax, the study said.
“Pennsylvania has had to rely on the gas tax to the point where the commonwealth has the highest gas tax in the country, or third in the country when considering all taxes applicable to gasoline (such as sales tax and other excise taxes specific to gasoline),” wrote LBFC Senior Analyst Stevi Sprenkle.
Technological advances are helping with road and bridge maintenance, the study said.
For roads, these include sensors to monitor pavement conditions, self-driving vehicles and traffic lights that promote traffic flow. For bridges, these include use of sensors, better materials and prefabricated bridge elements for use in repairs.
“While technology can be expensive, it allows for roads and bridges to have a longer lifespan,” said Rep. Jason Ortitay, R-South Fayette, sponsor of House Resolution 130 which authorized the study.
The study will help inform discussions on transportation funding and performance, said PennDOT Deputy Secretary Larry Shifflet.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.