The City of Pittsburgh’s infrastructure department unveiled its plan to replace the poorly rated Swinburne Bridge in a virtual hearing Thursday, but not without skepticism from residents of Four Mile Run — a community nestled below the bridge — over how construction will impact their neighborhood.

The Swinburne Bridge, a critical link between Four Mile Run, South Oakland, Greenfield, Hazelwood, and Downtown, was built in 1915 and serves as the gateway to Four Mile Run, the tight-knit neighborhood that sits at the bottom of a valley below Interstate 376.

But while DOMI was optimistic about the project, some citizens living in the neighborhoods near the bridge attended the hearing to suggest that the city had ulterior motives — either to use the span as a thoroughfare for the now-canceled Mon-Oakland Connector, or to potentially displace residents living in homes beneath it during construction.

The project is in its preliminary stages as engineers draft a design that DOMI said will be a “complete reconstruction” of the bridge. The project is a result of cooperation between the city, the Federal Highway Administration (FHWA) and the Pennsylvania Department of Transportation (PennDOT), DOMI said.

Advertise with us

While the new bridge will be built on the current bridge’s alignment, Matt Pierce, the lead structural engineer, explained that the rebuilt span would differ by having a 12-foot-wide multi-use path for bikes and pedestrians.

Four Mile Run residents were concerned that the city was possibly planning to use the path for shuttle access for the now-canceled Mon-Oakland Connector, a free shuttle service pushed by former Mayor Bill Peduto’s administration that Mayor Ed Gainey said this spring he would abandon.

Since the $25 million project was proposed, residents of Four Mile Run and neighboring Greenfield and Oakland pushed back, claiming it would disrupt traffic in their communities, harm air quality, endanger pedestrians and cut down on green spaces.

When DOMI was asked by resident Ray Girard to go on record and say that the city had no plan to use the bridge as part of the project, DOMI project manager Zachary Workman said there was “no intention and there never will be any intention to build out the bridge for the purpose of accommodating [the connector].”

“We are moving beyond that,” Mr. Workman said. “We are focusing on vehicles, pedestrians and bikes, and that will be our focus moving forward.”

Advertise with us

More skepticism was voiced by resident Mel Packer, who questioned the city’s top engineer as to why the 12-foot path led to “nowhere,” referencing an unfinished part of it seen on the Oakland side of the project’s plan.

Eric Setzler, the city’s chief engineer, confirmed to Mr. Packer that the designers were leaving that portion open for potential connections, but that those would be for bike travelers and not shuttles. Those projects, Mr. Setzler said, “were not necessarily funded right now” and not part of the Swinburne project.

Ziggy Edwards, another Four Mile Run resident, asked DOMI whether the city had plans to acquire homes beneath the bridge during construction, referencing a previous plan for the Mon-Oakland Connector that would have involved a widening project that would potentially displace homes below.

“My neighbors and I are very skeptical about this project and everything surrounding it, and with good reason,” added Ms. Edwards.

For the Swinburne project, Mr. Setzler said other bridge alignments were considered but eventually scrapped. The new bridge will be built on the current bridge’s alignment with the goal of “eliminating property impacts,” he said.

Advertise with us

Estimates for the cost of the project will total $15 million, with construction expected to begin in 2025. According to DOMI, the project will be 5% funded by the city, 15% by PennDOT, and 80% by funds from the federal government.

“The design team has been focusing on how to minimize impacts to those who rely on crossing the bridge daily or live and work in the vicinity, as well as how to improve usability for future generations of Pittsburghers,” wrote DOMI on the project’s webpage.

According to DOMI, the Swinburne’s span lacks design principles required for modern infrastructure. Records from the Allegheny County Bridge Report shows that the bridge is rated in overall poor condition; its superstructure and substructure earned poor ratings of 4 out of 9 on the National Bridge Inspection Standard scale.

The county’s bridge records show that its deck — the surface of the bridge —received a satisfactory rating of 6 out of 9.

Mr. Workman said the bridge’s superstructure exhibits deterioration and section loss, so much that the bridge’s load limited had to be restricted to 21 tons in 2014.

In addition to the reconstruction, DOMI said that the project would replace sidewalks; add a traffic signal at the intersection of Greenfield Avenue and Frazier Street; install a left-turn lane from eastbound Greenfield Avenue to northbound Frazier Street; and improve disability access ramps.