After trying unsuccessfully to meet and reason with state officials, three municipalities filed suit in Commonwealth Court Thursday to try to block the state Department of Transportation from implementing tolls on nine bridges across the state.

Officials from South Fayette, Collier and Bridgeville joined state Rep. Jason Ortitay and Sen. Devlin Robinson at a news conference Thursday to announce the lawsuit at Beacon I, a South Fayette office development. The development overlooks a bridge on Interstate 79 that could be part of the program to toll bridges the state says it can't afford to replace.

The state’s Public-Private Partnership Board last November authorized PennDOT to consider tolling as a way to pay for the replacement of key bridges that the department can’t replace through its regular funding. The 35-page lawsuit claims the state didn’t follow the board’s procedures that require the board to approve specific projects after their impact and need has been reviewed with local residents, noting that the projects weren’t identified until several months later.

Additionally, the suit claims the board’s decision to allow PennDOT to consider tolling should have required approval by the General Assembly but it was never presented there for review.

Advertise with us

As a result, legislators and local residents didn’t know tolling was a possibility for any specific bridge until the list was announced in February. That isn’t supposed to happen, said John M. Smith, special counsel to the municipalities who filed the suit.

“The (public-private partnership) statute isn’t designed to have surprises,” Mr. Smith said. “The problem is the process wasn’t followed.”

Mr. Ortitay, R-South Fayette, said if PennDOT had asked, it would have found little local support for the tolling option.

“Locally, everyone is opposed to this project,“ he said. “The only way to get this to stop and get their attention is to file suit.”

Mr. Robinson, R-Bridgeville, said those opposed to tolling have been frustrated by a lack of response from PennDOT about their concerns. There is reason to believe that tolls would begin before the bridge is replaced and continue long after it is done.

Advertise with us

“How does that make sense?” he said. “We feel there is no other option. We have to take this to Commonwealth Court.”

Gwen Rodi, president of the South Fayette commissioners, said it is particularly galling that the bridge under consideration for tolling is in very good condition. She believes PennDOT wants to revamp the interchange to three lanes in each direction to match the configuration of I-79 in Washington County, where lanes were added as part of the Pennsylvania Turnpike‘s recently opened Southern Beltway project.

“This bridge is not structurally deficient,” she said. “Why do they have to do this one?”

In addition, she said it would be a financial burden for local residents who have to use the road and would clog local roads with drivers avoiding tolls, hurting local businesses and further damaging local roads.

The suit was filed in Commonwealth Court because it involves a state agency, Mr. Smith said. Defendants PennDOT, the P3 board and PennDOT Secretary Yassmin Gramian have 30 days to respond, after which a hearing will be scheduled.

Advertise with us

PennDOT could not be reached for comment.

Although the suit involves only the I-79 bridge, the decision would apply to all of the bridges under review for tolling.

PennDOT began the process to toll the bridges earlier this year. The department has had a series of public meetings in communities around the bridges under review to determine how tolling would affect motorists and traffic on local roads and expects to receive formal proposals from three teams of contractors interested in performing the work early next year.

The suit claims the projects should have been identified and that review work should have been done before the P3 board voted on the concept.

PennDOT expects to get about $4 billion extra in federal funds over the next five years under the infrastructure bill approved last week, but it says it would still need to pursue options such as tolling because replacing those nine bridges would take more than half of the federal funds. The state claims it needs about $8.1 billion more each year to meet road and bridge needs.

Advertise with us

In addition to the lawsuit, there is a grassroots effort by residents to collect signatures from people opposing the project.

Coordinator Pete Winko of Cross Creek said the group had more than 6,000 signatures.

“People are just fed up,” Mr. Winko said. “I think it’s important that PennDOT listens to how this is going to take a toll on the people who drive through that area. This is unacceptable.“

Ed Blazina: eblazina@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1470 or on Twitter @EdBlazina.