It took a first-time-in-a-century pandemic and the economic downturn that goes with it, but automobile insurance rates are expected to go down in 2021 for the first time in 10 years.
According to an analysis of 15 million auto insurance quotes across the country by consumer website ValuePenguin.com, insurance rates will drop an average of 1.7% nationally. In Pennsylvania, which will rank 39th in the country for average cost of auto insurance at $1,194 a year, rates are projected to drop 3.4%, tied for the sixth highest drop.
ValuePenguin and the Insurance Information Institute attributed the decline to reduced driving resulting in fewer accidents during the pandemic. James Lynch, chief actuary for the institute, said Friday rates have increased an average of about 3% annually in recent years.
Insurance rates are set on a state-by-state basis determined by claims and state laws that control what has to be covered by insurance and how much victims can receive for damage claims.

For 2021, the biggest decrease is expected to be in Arkansas, where the cost should drop 4.8%. Ohio is tied with Michigan for the second spot at 4.3%, but Michigan’s change also is attributable to the state placing a cap on damage claims and the state’s average insurance cost remains more than double the next closest at $7,406 a year.
Mr. Lynch said the federal government’s Consumer Price Index tracks insurance prices on a monthly basis and the most recent report for November showed auto insurance rates down 6% compared to the previous year. A big part of that is because many insurers granted discounts worth an estimated $14 billion last year to drivers who were at less risk because they drove fewer miles after the pandemic broke out in March.
Many companies are building those discounts into rates for 2021, Mr. Lynch said.
“The rate is lower because people are driving less,” Mr. Lynch said, noting that during a lockdown period in the spring driving was down as much as 50%. “As the lockdown eased, the economy went down, and driving remains down about 15%. Those are the biggest reasons.”
Consumers also are taking steps to make sure their insurance company knows they are driving less.
The use of telematic devices that consumers install in vehicles to report driving habits to insurance companies, such as Drivewise for Allstate, increased from 30 to 40% to 40 to 50% of drivers last year. That indicates consumers want insurance companies to know they are driving less so they can receive immediate discounts on insurance, Mr. Lynch said.
The rates would have gone even lower, Mr. Lynch said, except for an unexpected result of less people on the road: more drivers are speeding and accidents that occur during increased speed cause more serious injuries and damage. The National Highway Transportation Safety Administration has reported that the rate of deaths per 100 million miles driven went up during 2020, apparently because open roads allowed more motorists to drive at excessive speeds.
“If people had slowed down, the rate would have been reduced even more,” Mr. Lynch said. “That’s safe to say.”
Unfortunately, telematic data shows that many motorists who substantially increased their driving speed when traffic was 50% below normal last spring have not slowed down as traffic increased, Mr. Lynch said.
Now, the question is whether rates will continue to go down, stabilize or increase again in 2022. ValuePenguin said the decrease is likely a one-year situation, but Mr. Lynch said it’s too early to say and depends on the return to pre-pandemic miles driven.
After the 2008 recession led to a decline in driving, it took until 2013 for driving habits to return to the pre-recession level.
“That’s the $10,000 question, isn’t it?” Mr. Lynch said. “It there’s slow economic growth, the rates will remain stable. The rate of return to miles driven before the pandemic will determine whether there’s upward pressure on rates.”
Ed Blazina: eblazina@post-gazdette.com, 412-263-1470 or on Twitter @EdBlazina.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.