This is the dilemma facing most families: Should they break more than eight months of near isolation to share Thanksgiving with family or friends? Or should they follow medical advice to stay home and avoid contact with anyone outside their household due to the surging COVID-19 pandemic?

John Weingarden, a psychologist and senior director at UPMC Western Psychiatric Hospital, said he understands the anxiety that comes with making such important life decisions. The key, he said, is weighing the risks before deciding whether it’s the right time to make that trip over the river and through the woods.

Here’s how varied the projections are about travel for Thanksgiving: In AAA’s projection 10 days ago, the agency estimated holiday travel would be down about 10% compared to 2019 across the country and about 13% in the mid-Atlantic region of Pennsylvania, New Jersey and New York.

Meanwhile, travel and navigation app GasBuddy last week estimated only 35% of Americans will travel for Thanksgiving, compared to 65% last year.

Advertise with us

To go or not to go is a serious decision that should be treated that way, Mr. Weingarden said.

Although many medical experts predicted an increase in virus cases this fall, Mr. Weingarden said it is unfortunate that is it coming just before the holiday season begins. After dealing with varying restrictions since March, he said, many people set a goal to be done dealing with the pandemic by the holidays.

“’[Getting together at Thanksgiving] will just get me through the fall’ is what a lot of people were thinking,” he said. “At this point, I think the exhaustion of all this is setting in. Stress wears on us and it can become physical.”

In this instance, there’s also another factor to the pandemic beyond the medical or emotional concerns: It’s also become a hot political issue, bringing more potential inter-personal tension to the decision if some family members don’t agree with the potential danger.

Mr. Weingarten said most people aren’t good at assessing risk and following through on what they learn, which is why millions buy tickets for state lotteries with huge odds against winning. He suggested that people assess the risks of a holiday get-together in common terms.

Advertise with us

For example, the current positivity rate for people tested for COVID-19 is about 6%, which some might consider an acceptable risk. But Mr. Weingarden said most people would not take their chances on a pack of 30 M&Ms if they knew two were poisonous, and that’s about the same ratio.

“We need to make the risk assessment in terms we can understand,” he said. “If you’re going to a family gathering with 15 people, there’s a good chance someone is going to be positive and that’s a high-risk situation.”

It’s important to be “mentally prepared” to have a conversation about turning down an invitation, Mr. Weingarden said, so you can stick to your decision.

“Saying, ‘No, I’m not going to come’ could be hard to say or taken offensively,” he said. “People may experience a lot of guilt about not wanting to visit. Say ‘this is how I feel right now and it’s important to me.’”

Holiday and family traditions are compelling forces, Mr. Weingarden acknowledged, so it’s important that people find ways to maintain them even if not in person. Virtual gatherings are one way to share with others but even if families or individuals are by themselves it is important to mark occasions to avoid depression, even if it means cooking a piece of turkey breast and instant mashed potatoes to enjoy by yourself.

Advertise with us

“It’s important to focus on what you can do, not what you can’t,” he said.

Mr. Weingarden, who works extensively with geriatric patients, said holidays can be a double-edged sword for seniors. They can long for traditions but feel sad when they realize others they cared about are no longer there.

As the pandemic has gone on, Mr. Weingarden said, he’s had more patients seeking his care because they were having trouble handling isolation that has come with the pandemic.

If people decide not to go to a Thanksgiving gathering, Mr. Weingarden said, it will be easier to make the same decision at Christmas if conditions don’t improve.

“It’s easier to keep your guard up once you make the decision not to go,” he said. “If you go and you’re lucky that nothing happens, then you’re more likely to go again. It can be a really slippery slope.”

Advertise with us

Overall, Mr. Weingarden recommends taking a long view of holiday gatherings.

“It’s really just one season. It doesn’t mean you can never get together. I think we need to make long-range plans. Think of something we can do together next spring or summer and look forward to that.”

Ed Blazina: eblazina@post-gazette.com., 412-263-1470 or on Twitter @EdBlazina.